Using Your Mental Health Benefits Before December 31, and What Resets in January
It’s a weeknight in November, and you open your insurance app to check on a claim. Near the top is a line you usually scroll past: your deductible, and how much of it you’ve already met this year. Between a few doctor visits and the therapy you started in the spring, the bar is almost full. Then a thought arrives: if I’ve already paid this much, should I be using my mental health benefits before December 31? Often, yes. If your plan year ends December 31 and you’ve met most or all of your deductible, sessions before then often cost you less than the same sessions in January, when many plans start counting from zero again. Whether that’s true for you depends on your plan year, what’s left on your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, and how your plan handles copays. You can find out before you book.
Want your own numbers before the year runs out? Send us your plan details for a free benefits check, or contact us with a question first. We offer individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy, teen therapy and medication management (Florida, New Jersey, Colorado and North Carolina only), by secure video in most states we serve and in person in Wellington, Florida (full list below).
This post is about timing: what the end of the plan year means for therapy, and what to expect when January starts. If you want the basics of copays, deductibles and coinsurance first, our guide to using insurance for therapy explains each one.
Why December 31 Can Change What a Session Costs You
Your share of a therapy session isn’t fixed. It depends on where you are in your plan year, and three counters do most of the work:
- Your deductible. Until it’s met, many plans have you pay the full rate they’ve agreed with the therapist. After it’s met, you usually pay a smaller share.
- Your copay or coinsurance. This is your share after the deductible (and on some plans, from the first visit).
- Your out-of-pocket maximum. Once you reach it, your plan usually pays for covered in-network care in full for the rest of the plan year.
All three start over when your plan year renews. Many plans run on the calendar year, so the reset lands on January 1. Employer plans can renew in another month, though, so don’t assume. What counts is the date of the session, not the date you pay: a session on December 29 counts toward this year’s totals, and a session on January 4 counts toward next year’s.
So if you’ve already met your deductible, or you’re close to your out-of-pocket maximum, the last weeks of the year can be a lower-cost window. If you haven’t met much of your deductible, the calendar matters less, because January won’t look very different from December.
Four Questions to Answer Before the Year Ends
You can usually find these answers in your plan’s member portal or app, or by calling the member services number on the back of your card. Or let us ask for you.
- When does my plan year end? December 31 for many plans, but check. If yours renews in July, the year-end rush doesn’t apply to you.
- How much of my deductible and out-of-pocket maximum is left? Ask for the in-network and out-of-network amounts separately, because many plans track them apart. Money you spent on other medical care this year may already count toward the same deductible.
- What do I pay for outpatient mental health visits right now? Ask whether your copay applies before or after the deductible, and whether video sessions are covered the same way as office visits.
- Is anything changing on January 1? A new job, a new plan from open enrollment, or the same insurer with a different plan design can all change your costs and whether a therapist is in network.
Our free benefits check covers the first three. Fill in our insurance verification form and we’ll ask your plan what you’d pay for therapy and where your deductible stands, then email you what we find, usually within a couple of hours. We check medication management visits too. The check commits you to nothing, and what we send is what your plan tells us. The final amount is set when the plan processes the claim, so treat it as a close estimate, not a promise.
If You’ve Met Your Deductible: Making the Most of December
If the numbers say this is a good window, a few practical points help:
- Start the paperwork early. Our intake forms need to be completed before your first appointment can be booked, and December has fewer working days than most months. If you’re new, reach out in November rather than the week before the holidays.
- Ask about times now. Holiday weeks are busy for everyone, so it helps to look at the calendar together sooner rather than later.
- You can’t prepay to lock in this year’s rate. We bill per session, with no packages and nothing to buy up front, and your plan credits each session by its date.
- Let the pace fit the work, not the calendar. Squeezing in extra sessions just to beat December 31 isn’t a reason on its own. Talk with your therapist about how often to meet based on what you’re working on.
Coming for couples or family therapy? Coverage for those sessions varies more than coverage for individual therapy, so check before you count on the year-end math. Our guide, Does Insurance Cover Couples or Family Therapy? By State, shows which plans we’re in network with in each state and what to ask about couples and family sessions.
Not sure where your deductible stands? Let us check your benefits, or send us a message and we’ll walk you through the next step.
What Changes When Your Deductible Resets in January
January is when a lot of people are surprised by a therapy bill that looks higher than December’s. Nothing about the session changed. The counters did. Here’s what to expect:
- Your share may go up for a while. If your plan has a deductible, you may pay the plan’s full agreed rate for each session until you’ve met it again. That rate is set by your plan, not by us.
- Your copay or coinsurance may change. Plans can change these amounts at renewal, even when you keep the same insurer.
- A new plan needs a new check. If you’re switching plans or jobs, send us the new details through the verification form before your first January session. Whether we’re in network depends on the plan and the state, so a new card can change the answer. Our insurer guides for Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare explain how each one handles therapy.
- Your out-of-pocket maximum starts over too. If you reached it this year, covered in-network sessions may have cost you little or nothing lately. Expect that to change after the reset.
A higher January bill isn’t a reason to stop therapy that’s helping. If the cost worries you, say so to your therapist. You can talk about how often to meet, and we can check your new numbers so there are no surprises.
FSAs, HSAs and Out-of-Network Claims at Year End
Two kinds of accounts and one kind of claim have their own year-end rules.
Flexible spending accounts (FSAs) often have a deadline for using the money, and your employer decides whether you get a grace period or a carryover. Health savings accounts (HSAs) work differently: the money generally stays yours from year to year. The rules for your account come from your employer or plan administrator, so check with them before you plan around a deadline. You can use an HSA or FSA card to pay us, for a copay or for a full session.
If you see us out of network, sessions this year count toward this year’s out-of-network deductible, by date of service. Plans often set a deadline for filing claims, so send your superbills in regularly rather than saving a year’s worth. Our guide to out-of-network therapy reimbursement explains how superbills and claims work, step by step. In Georgia, we’re not in network with any plan yet, so Georgia clients pay per session and can file out-of-network claims with a superbill.
If Insurance Won’t Help Much Right Now
Sometimes the check comes back with no mental health coverage you can use, or a deductible so high that the calendar doesn’t matter. You can still see us and pay out of pocket. Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR sessions, each 45–50 minutes, and $200–$250 for an extended 90-minute individual, couples or EMDR session. You can ask for a written Good Faith Estimate before your first session, and there is no set number of sessions. Our post on self-pay therapy without insurance covers paying this way.
We’ll be candid, too: if we aren’t in network with your plan and paying out of pocket isn’t workable, a therapist who is in network with your plan may be the better route. Your plan’s provider directory lists them. Getting care matters more than getting it from us.
You do not need a diagnosis or a referral to start. Just tell us a little about what is going on and we will match you with a clinician licensed in your state.
And if you’re struggling right now, don’t wait for a new plan year. Call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, any time. If you or someone else is in danger, call 911.
FAQs
Does my deductible reset on January 1?
It does if your plan runs on the calendar year, which many do. Some employer plans renew in a different month. Your summary of benefits or member portal shows your plan year, or we can check it for you.
Do therapy sessions count toward my deductible?
Often, yes. On many plans, outpatient mental health visits count toward the same deductible as your other medical care. Plans differ, and some have a separate out-of-network deductible, so ask how yours works.
Can I use my FSA or HSA for therapy?
Therapy is often an eligible expense, and you can use an HSA or FSA card to pay us. What your account allows, and any year-end deadline, depends on your account’s rules, so check with your plan administrator.
If I change insurance in January, can I keep my therapist?
Often you can, but it depends on whether we’re in network with the new plan in your state. Send us the new plan details before your first January session and we’ll tell you what changes. If we aren’t in network with the new plan, you can ask about out-of-network benefits or self-pay.
Is it worth starting therapy in December?
If you’ve been meaning to start and you’ve met your deductible, December can cost you less. But the right time to start is when you’re ready. The work keeps going in January, and a benefits check shows what you’d pay on either side of the reset.
Where We Work
We offer individual therapy by secure video in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, North Carolina, South Carolina, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Tennessee, Rhode Island and Georgia. You need to be physically in the state at the time of your session. In-person sessions are available at our Wellington, Florida office; in-person times in Cary, North Carolina are full right now, so new North Carolina clients start by video. All New Jersey, Illinois and Georgia sessions are by secure video. Meet the clinicians on our therapists page.
- Using Insurance for Therapy: Copays, Deductibles and What You’ll Actually Pay
- Does Insurance Cover Couples or Family Therapy? By State
- Out-of-Network Therapist Reimbursement: How It Actually Works
- Self-Pay Therapy: Rates and Options Without Insurance
- How Much Does Online Therapy Cost?
- Online Couples Therapy Cost: What You Pay, With or Without Insurance
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
