You moved from New Jersey to North Carolina, kept the job, kept the insurance, and the card still says Blue Cross Blue Shield. So you assume your coverage moved with you. Then a receptionist asks which Blue plan you have and you realize you have no idea that was a question, let alone what the answer is.
It is a question, and it has a straightforward answer we can find for you. Send your plan details through our insurance verification form and we will tell you exactly what your plan covers here, or contact us and we will work through it together. Blue plans commonly cover individual therapy, family therapy, trauma therapy and EMDR, psychiatry and medication management and, when it is part of treating a diagnosis, couples therapy. We see clients in Florida, New York, North Carolina, Colorado and New Jersey, among twelve states in total.
Quick answers
- Does Blue Cross cover therapy? Yes. Most commercial Blue Cross Blue Shield plans cover outpatient therapy, including online sessions, at your plan’s usual copay, coinsurance or deductible.
- Does Blue Cross cover couples or marriage counseling? Usually only when one partner has a diagnosed condition and the couples work is part of treating it.
- Is New Reflections in network with Blue Cross? In most of our states, yes. We are out of network with BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina (and with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois, except for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC); there we give you a superbill for out-of-network benefits.
- What do the three letters on my card mean? They identify which Blue company issued your plan. Send them with your group number and we’ll check your benefits.
Blue Cross is not one company
This is the single most useful thing to understand about Blue coverage, and almost nobody is told it. “Blue Cross Blue Shield” is a federation of independent, locally owned companies — around thirty-three of them — licensed to use the same name and symbol. They set their own networks, negotiate their own contracts and make their own coverage decisions.
So Florida Blue and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina are not branches of one organization. They are separate companies that share a brand. A practice can be in network with one and not the other, and that is not an inconsistency — it is two different contracts with two different businesses. It also explains why a friend’s experience with “Blue Cross” may bear no relation to yours.
The three letters at the start of your member ID
Look at your card. Most Blue member IDs begin with a three-character alphabetical prefix before the numbers. That prefix identifies which Blue company issued your plan — your “home plan” — and it is the first thing any provider’s billing office looks for.
It is the fastest way to answer “which Blue do I have,” and it is worth knowing where to find it, because the front of the card often does not name the company in plain language. When you contact us, that prefix plus the group number tells us almost everything we need to start.
Which Blue company covers our states
For orientation, the Blue licensee in each of the states we work in is generally: Florida Blue in Florida; Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in New York, Connecticut and Colorado; Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina; Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey; BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina — the one exception, and we explain that below; Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois; Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island; and BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee.
Pennsylvania is the instructive exception: it is divided among several Blue companies by region, including Independence Blue Cross around Philadelphia, Highmark in the west and Capital Blue Cross through the center of the state. If Pennsylvania has three, the idea that “Blue Cross” is one national company does not survive contact with reality.
South Carolina: we are out of network with BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina
We would rather say this plainly than let you discover it at the front desk. We have an office in Greenville, but we are not in network with BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina. If that is your plan, we are an out-of-network provider for you.
That is not the same as being unable to see you, and plenty of people see us out of network. If your BCBSSC plan is a PPO carrying out-of-network benefits, it may reimburse a meaningful share of the fee once an out-of-network deductible is met, and we can provide a superbill — the itemized receipt with diagnosis and procedure codes — for you to submit directly. Our self-pay rate is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR, and HSA and FSA funds can be used for it.
What we will not do is let you book on the assumption that your card is going to be accepted. If you are in South Carolina and cost is the deciding factor, tell us at the outset and we will be straight with you about what care would actually cost before you commit to anything.
Using an out-of-state Blue plan with us: BlueCard
This is where the federation works in your favor. The BlueCard program lets you use your home plan’s benefits with a provider who participates with the local Blue company. Your claim is filed locally, routed to your home plan, and paid under your home plan’s benefits.
For a practice like ours that is genuinely useful. It means someone holding a Horizon card from New Jersey can often be seen by video in North Carolina, without being treated as out of network. It is also why the honest answer to “do you take Blue Cross” is “let us check your specific plan” rather than a flat yes or no — the routing depends on your home plan and on which local contracts apply.
Does Blue Cross Blue Shield cover therapy?
On commercial Blue plans, almost always. Outpatient mental health is a standard medical benefit, and federal parity rules require most plans to cover it on terms no more restrictive than physical health care. Your sessions run through the same deductible and cost-sharing structure as any other specialist visit.
The amount varies by plan rather than by carrier, and with Blue it varies by company as well. Two people in different states, both holding cards with the same symbol, can have entirely different deductibles, copays and networks. That is why we verify rather than quote.
The Blue plans we can and cannot take
Commercial and employer plans — the PPO, HMO, EPO and POS products bought through work — are what we are set up for, with the South Carolina exception noted above.
Medicaid managed care products sold under Blue branding are outside what we take. These carry names like Healthy Blue, Blue Cross Community or similar, and they vary by state. We are not Medicaid providers anywhere we work.
Medicare Advantage plans under a Blue brand are likewise outside what we take. We are not enrolled with Medicare, and a Medicare Advantage plan runs on Medicare’s rules whatever the logo. If you are in either group, our self-pay rate is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR.
If you are a federal employee
The Blue Cross Blue Shield Service Benefit Plan — the Federal Employee Program, usually shortened to FEP — is the plan most federal workers and retirees hold. Its member IDs begin with the letter R, which is the quickest way to recognize one.
FEP is administered nationally rather than by a single local Blue, and its benefit structure differs from commercial plans. It is generally a strong plan for outpatient mental health. Tell us if you have one, because we verify it through a different route than a standard commercial Blue plan.
Do you need a referral?
On most Blue commercial plans, no. Self-referral to behavioral health is the norm and you can book with us directly. Some HMO designs do still require a primary care referral, and because each Blue company sets its own rules, this is one of the areas where they genuinely differ from each other. If your card says HMO, it is worth confirming — and we check it when we verify benefits.
Does Blue Cross Blue Shield cover couples therapy or marriage counseling?
Usually only when one partner has a diagnosed condition, such as depression, PTSD or an anxiety disorder, and the couples sessions are part of treating it. Relationship distress alone is generally not covered. We verify your benefits free before you start and tell you which situation you’re in, rather than leaving a denied claim to explain it.
Where one partner carries a diagnosis such as depression, PTSD or an anxiety disorder and involving the partner is genuinely part of treating it, sessions can be billed as family therapy with the diagnosed person as the client. That has to be clinically true before it can be coded that way. We will tell you which situation you are in at the start rather than leaving a denied claim to explain it later. More on this in our guide to couples and family therapy coverage in every state we serve.
Online therapy on a Blue plan
Telehealth for behavioral health is standard on commercial Blue plans and normally covered at the same cost share as an in-person session. The rule that governs it is licensure: what matters is the state you are physically in during the appointment, not where your therapist sits.
Given how often Blue members are covered by a plan from a state they no longer live in, this is worth raising early. Where you live, where your plan was issued and where your clinician is licensed are three separate facts, and all three need to line up. We would far rather sort that out before your first session than in the middle of treatment.
What we need in order to check your benefits
We need the member ID exactly as printed — including that three-letter prefix — the group number, the subscriber’s name and date of birth, and the state you will physically be in for sessions. If you know which Blue company issued the plan, tell us; if you do not, the prefix will tell us.
What comes back is whether the deductible applies to outpatient behavioral health and how much of it remains, the copay or coinsurance after that, and whether anything requires authorization. The standard caveat applies and we would rather state it: a benefits quote is an estimate of coverage, not a guarantee of payment. It holds up in the large majority of cases, and we will tell you promptly if a claim comes back differently.
If we turn out to be out of network on your plan
With Blue this happens more often than with single-company carriers, simply because there are more companies and more contracts. It is not a dead end. Many Blue PPO plans carry out-of-network benefits that reimburse a substantial share once an out-of-network deductible is met, and we can provide a superbill — the itemized receipt with diagnosis and procedure codes — for you to submit directly. HSA and FSA funds can be used for therapy as well.
If you are comparing carriers rather than plans, we have written the same breakdown for Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare and Tricare.
Common questions
Do you take Blue Cross Blue Shield?
In most cases yes, but the honest answer depends on which Blue company issued your plan, because they are separate businesses with separate contracts. The two we know we are out of network with are BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois, except that Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois is in network for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC. Send us the member ID prefix and group number and we will give you a definite answer rather than a probable one.
Do you take BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina?
No. We are out of network with BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina. You can still be seen on an out-of-network or self-pay basis, and we will tell you what that costs before you book. Our self-pay rate is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR.
Do you take Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois?
Yes, for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC, by secure video. Other Illinois sessions, such as EMDR with Lisa Abrotsky or LaShaunda Miles, are out of network with BCBS of Illinois. If your plan has out-of-network benefits, we give you a superbill after every session to submit for reimbursement, and our self-pay rate is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR.
My Blue Cross plan is from another state. Can I still be seen?
Often yes, through the BlueCard program, which lets your home plan’s benefits travel. Your clinician still has to be licensed in the state you are physically in for sessions, so those two things are checked together.
How much does therapy cost with Blue Cross?
Once any deductible is met, most people on an employer Blue plan pay a per-session copay or a coinsurance percentage. Before it is met you may owe the contracted rate, which is lower than our self-pay fee. The range is wide enough that quoting a number without seeing your plan would be guessing.
What do the three letters on my Blue Cross card mean?
They identify which Blue company issued your plan — your home plan. It is the first thing a billing office looks for, and it is how we work out which rules apply to you.
Does Blue Cross Blue Shield cover out-of-network therapy?
Many Blue PPO plans do, once an out-of-network deductible is met; HMO and EPO plans usually don’t. We’re out of network with BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina (and with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois, except for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC), and there we give you a superbill after each session to submit for reimbursement.
How many therapy sessions does Blue Cross Blue Shield cover?
Many commercial Blue plans set no fixed yearly limit on outpatient therapy, because federal parity rules restrict caps that are stricter than those on medical care. Some plans review ongoing care for medical necessity or require authorization. We check your specific plan, including any limits, before your first session.
Will my employer find out I am in therapy?
No. Your employer buys or funds the plan but does not receive your claims or your records. The insurer receives only what is needed to process a claim — dates of service, procedure codes and a diagnosis code — and never the content of your sessions.
Where we work
We have offices in Wellington, Florida; White Plains, New York; Cary, North Carolina; Greenwood Village, Colorado; Greenville, South Carolina; and Princeton, New Jersey — we see clients in person only in Wellington and Cary, and by video across all twelve states we are licensed in: Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee. Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video. You can also meet our therapists and see who works in your state.
