Using Insurance for Therapy: Copays, Deductibles and What You’ll Actually Pay
You sent the contact form, someone called you back, and the clinician you were matched with is licensed in your state. You even heard the words you were hoping for: “We’re in network with your plan.” But a second question shows up while you look at your insurance card: if they take my insurance, do I still have to pay anything? Usually, yes. When a therapist is in network, your plan pays part of each session and you pay your share, which is a flat copay, a percentage called coinsurance, or, until your deductible is met, the full rate your plan has agreed to. Which of those applies depends on your plan and the point you’ve reached in your plan year, not on the therapist. At New Reflections Counseling, we’ll look up your share for free and send it to you before you book a first session.
Ready to find out your number? Check your insurance or contact us. Our clinicians provide individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy and teen therapy over secure video in the states where we hold a license (full list below).
This page covers the in-network case: what “we take your insurance” means for your wallet and why the amount can change during the year. Paying privately or out of network? The links near the end cover those.
If a Therapist Takes Your Insurance, Do You Still Pay?
In most cases you pay something. “In network” means the therapist has a contract with your insurer. The contract sets a price for each type of session, and the plan agrees to cover part of that price. Your plan’s cost-sharing rules decide the rest, and those rules are written into your plan, not set by the therapist.
There are three common outcomes for a single session:
- You pay a copay. A flat amount per visit, the same every time. Some plans charge it from the first session; others only after the deductible is met.
- You pay the whole contracted rate. This happens when your plan has a deductible you haven’t met yet. Every dollar you pay goes toward that deductible.
- You pay coinsurance. After the deductible is met, you pay a percentage of the contracted rate and the plan pays the rest.
What you don’t pay in network is the gap between the therapist’s usual fee and the contracted rate. The contract covers that difference, which is one of the real advantages of staying in network.
Copay, Deductible, Coinsurance: What Each Word Means for a Therapy Session
Here is each term as it applies to one therapy visit.
Contracted rate (sometimes called the allowed amount or negotiated rate): the price your plan and the therapist agreed on for that kind of session. It is set by the contract, not by a practice’s self-pay rate card, and it can differ from plan to plan.
Deductible: the amount that comes out of your own pocket in a plan year before your insurer begins to pay its part. The plan year often starts in January, but employer plans can start in any month. Mental health visits often count toward the same deductible as your medical care, but plans differ, so ask.
Copay: a fixed dollar amount per visit. Your card may print one, but the number on the card isn’t always the one for outpatient mental health, so confirm it.
Coinsurance: a percentage of the contracted rate that you pay after the deductible is met. If your coinsurance is 20%, you pay one fifth of the contracted rate and the plan pays the other four fifths.
Out-of-pocket maximum: the ceiling on what you pay for covered in-network care in a plan year. Once you reach it, the plan pays for covered in-network services in full until the year resets.
Why the Same Session Can Cost Different Amounts in March and November
The most common surprise isn’t the copay. It’s the deductible. Until you’ve met your deductible, you usually pay the plan’s full contracted rate for each session. Once it’s met, you pay your copay or coinsurance share, and if you reach your out-of-pocket maximum, your share of covered in-network sessions drops to nothing until the plan year resets.
On a plan with a flat copay and no deductible for outpatient mental health, the same session might cost you only the copay from the first visit.
Money you spent on other medical care this year may already count toward your deductible, so check before you assume you’re starting from zero. And if your plan year resets soon, expect your share to rise for a while afterward.
What You’ll Pay at New Reflections Counseling
- Who we’re in network with: Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare (behavioral health through Optum), Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare.
- The exceptions: Blue Cross Blue Shield isn’t in network for clients in South Carolina. In Illinois, Tricare and UnitedHealthcare are out of network, and Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois is in network only for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC, so Illinois clients can use Aetna or Cigna in network, or Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois with Jaime. In several states we also work with regional plans; the benefits check covers those too.
- What we don’t take: Medicare or Medicaid.
- What you pay when we’re in network: your plan’s copay, coinsurance or deductible amount for each session, the same cost-sharing your plan applies to other in-network outpatient mental health visits. We don’t add a separate fee on top for being in network.
- Therapy session length: 45–50 minutes, the same for individual, couples, family and EMDR sessions.
- How fast you can start: most people are seen within a week. There’s no free consultation; your first appointment is an intake session with the clinician you’re matched with.
A carrier’s name on that list is a strong start, not a guarantee. Insurers sell many plans under one brand, and a particular employer plan can sit outside our contract. That’s why we check.
The check is free and commits you to nothing. Fill in our insurance verification form with your plan details, and we find out: whether telehealth is covered, your copay or coinsurance, and how much of your deductible you’ve met. You get the results by email within a couple of hours. What we send you is what your plan tells us. The final figure is set when the plan processes the claim, so treat the check as a close estimate rather than a promise.
Rather know your share before you commit? Run the free insurance check, or get in touch to be matched with a clinician who holds a license where you live.
Why You Might Get a Bill Even Though We’re In Network
A bill from an in-network practice can feel like a mistake. Usually it isn’t. The common reasons:
- Your deductible wasn’t met yet. The plan counted the session toward your deductible, so the contracted rate came back to you.
- Your coinsurance applied. The plan paid its percentage, and the balance is your share.
- Your plan year reset. January (or whenever your plan renews) starts the deductible over.
- Your specific plan isn’t under our contract. The benefits check is meant to catch this before your first session.
- The plan denied or adjusted the claim. Plans sometimes need more information, and claims can be resubmitted or appealed.
Your plan sends you an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) after each claim. It isn’t a bill. It shows the contracted rate, what the plan paid and what it says you owe. If a bill from us doesn’t match your EOB, ask us, and we’ll look into it with you.
What “Upfront Pricing” Means When You Have a Deductible
A posted price and your insured cost are different numbers. A posted self-pay price is what you pay when insurance isn’t billed. When insurance is billed, the posted price doesn’t decide your share. Your deductible, copay and coinsurance do, applied to the contracted rate.
So when you see an upfront quote, ask one question: does this number factor in my plan? Our rate card doesn’t, because it’s the self-pay price. Our benefits check does, because it starts from what your plan reports about you.
If Your Plan Isn’t One We Take
At New Reflections Counseling, self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR. HSA and FSA cards can be used whether you’re paying a copay or the full self-pay rate. If your plan has out-of-network benefits, we provide a superbill you can submit for partial reimbursement.
Each of those routes has its own guide:
- For the full self-pay picture, read therapy without insurance.
- To see how reimbursement works step by step, read out-of-network therapy reimbursement.
- For prices by session type and how online sessions are billed, read how much online therapy costs.
- Couples sessions follow their own coverage rules, covered in does insurance cover marriage therapy.
Questions That Get You a Real Number
If you’d like to call your plan yourself, use the member services number on your card. These questions are written for the in-network case:
- For an in-network outpatient psychotherapy visit, do I owe a copay, coinsurance or both?
- Does that copay apply right away, or only after my deductible?
- What is my deductible this plan year, and how much is still left?
- What is my in-network out-of-pocket maximum, and how close am I?
- Are video sessions covered at the same cost share as office visits?
- When does my plan year start over?
Note the date, the representative’s name and the call reference number, in case an answer later turns out to be wrong.
Each carrier handles therapy a little differently. Our guides cover Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare one by one.
FAQs
If a therapist accepts my insurance, do I have to pay?
Usually you pay part of the cost: a copay, coinsurance, or the full contracted rate until your deductible is met. The plan pays the rest. A benefits check before your first session tells you which applies to you right now.
Can I use my HSA or FSA card for a therapy copay?
Yes. At New Reflections, HSA and FSA cards can be used for a copay or for the full self-pay rate.
Is my copay the same for video sessions?
That varies by plan. Many plans treat telehealth therapy the same as an office visit, but not all do. Ask your plan, or let our benefits check confirm whether telehealth is covered.
What if I can’t wait for a benefits check?
If you’re in crisis, skip the paperwork. Call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or call 911 if you’re in immediate danger.
Where We Work
New Reflections Counseling holds licenses in 12 states: Florida, Georgia, New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, North Carolina, South Carolina, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Tennessee and Rhode Island. Whatever your home address, you need to be physically in one of these states during each session. Nearly all of our work happens over secure video. In-person sessions are offered only in Wellington, Florida, and Cary, North Carolina; Cary’s in-person times are full at the moment, so new North Carolina clients begin by video. To see what’s available where you are, open your state’s page; to meet the people you’d be working with, visit our therapists page.
- How Much Does Online Therapy Cost?
- Out-of-Network Therapist Reimbursement: How It Actually Works
- Self-Pay Therapy: Rates and Options Without Insurance
- Does Insurance Cover Couples or Family Therapy? A State-by-State Guide
- How to Schedule a Therapy Appointment: What to Expect
- Therapy That Moves With You: Licensed in Twelve States
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
