Your card says Cigna. You call the behavioral health number on the back of it, and the person who answers says “Evernorth.” You check the card again. Nothing on it says Evernorth. At this point a reasonable person concludes they have dialed the wrong company and gives up for another few months.
You have not dialed the wrong company, and we can sort this out in a few minutes. We are in network with Cigna — the fastest route is to send your plan details through our insurance verification form and let us run the benefits, or contact us and we will do it on the phone with you. Cigna plans commonly cover individual therapy, family therapy, teen therapy, trauma therapy and EMDR and psychiatry and medication management. We see clients in Florida, New York, North Carolina, Colorado and New Jersey, among twelve states in total.
Quick answers
- Does Cigna cover therapy? Yes. Most commercial Cigna plans cover outpatient therapy, including online sessions, through Evernorth Behavioral Health at your plan’s usual copay, coinsurance or deductible.
- Why does it say Evernorth? Evernorth is Cigna’s behavioral health arm. Your therapy claims go through Evernorth even though your card says Cigna.
- Cigna EAP vs Evernorth: what’s the difference? An EAP is a short set of free counseling sessions your employer provides, often 3 to 8 a year, separate from your insurance. Evernorth is your regular mental health coverage under your Cigna plan. An EAP needs an authorization code before the first session. We do not accept EAP authorizations; we bill your Evernorth coverage.
- Does Cigna cover couples therapy? Usually only when one partner has a diagnosed condition and the couples work is part of treating it. Relationship distress alone is generally not covered.
- Is New Reflections in network with Cigna? Yes. We check your specific plan for you, usually within a couple of hours.
Why your mental health benefits say Evernorth
Evernorth is Cigna’s health services arm, and behavioral health sits inside it. When Cigna reorganized its businesses, the mental health side took the Evernorth name while the insurance card kept the Cigna logo. Your therapy claims are processed under Evernorth Behavioral Health; your medical claims stay with Cigna.
Practically, this means two things. The phone number for mental health on your card may be different from the general member services number, and the provider directory for therapists is a different directory from the one for physicians. If you search the main Cigna doctor directory and do not find us, that is the wrong directory rather than an answer about our network status. It is one of the more common reasons someone decides a practice does not take their plan when it does.
Does Cigna cover therapy?
On essentially every commercial Cigna plan, yes. Outpatient mental health is a standard medical benefit. Federal parity law requires most plans to cover behavioral health on terms no more restrictive than those applied to physical health, so your sessions generally run through the same deductible, copay or coinsurance structure as any other specialist visit.
The variable is the shape of that cost share, and it is set by whoever bought the plan rather than by Cigna centrally. One person pays a flat copay from session one. Another pays the full contracted rate until a deductible is met. Both have Cigna cards. This is why we ask for the member ID and group number rather than the carrier name — the carrier name alone genuinely cannot tell you what you will pay.
The Cigna plans we can and cannot take
Open Access Plus (OAP) is Cigna’s most common employer network and the one we see most often. LocalPlus is a narrower, lower-cost network built around specific geographies — worth flagging, because a LocalPlus plan can behave differently from an OAP plan issued by the same employer in a different state. Standard PPO, HMO and EPO products are also ones we are set up for.
Medicare Advantage plans under the Cigna brand are outside what we take. We are not enrolled with Medicare, and a Medicare Advantage plan runs on Medicare’s rules whatever logo is printed on the card. The same applies to any Medicaid managed care product — we are not Medicaid providers in any of our states.
If that is your situation, it is not the end of the conversation. Our self-pay rate is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR, and a good number of people choose it deliberately rather than as a fallback.
If your employer self-funds, Cigna may only be the administrator
Many large employers pay claims out of their own funds and hire Cigna to administer the plan. The card looks identical. The difference is that the benefit design — what is covered, at what rate, with what limits — is set by your employer, not by Cigna.
This matters because it explains something that otherwise looks like an error: two people at two companies, both holding Cigna cards, can get genuinely different answers about the same service. Neither was told wrong. When we verify benefits we are reading your specific plan document, which is the only thing that actually governs what you pay.
Do you need a referral?
For most Cigna commercial plans, no. Self-referral to behavioral health is standard and you can book with us directly. Some HMO designs still route through a primary care physician, and LocalPlus plans can be stricter about staying inside a defined network. If your card says HMO or LocalPlus, that is worth confirming before the first session, and we will check it as part of verifying your benefits.
Prior authorization for routine outpatient therapy is uncommon on Cigna commercial plans. It shows up more often for higher levels of care such as intensive outpatient programs, which is not what we provide.
Does Cigna cover couples therapy or marriage counseling?
Usually only when one partner has a diagnosed condition, such as depression, PTSD or an anxiety disorder, and the couples sessions are part of treating it; then they can be billed as family therapy for that partner. Relationship distress alone is generally not covered. We verify your benefits free and tell you which applies before you start. If you’re weighing self-pay instead, see what online couples therapy costs.
Couples work can be covered when one partner carries a diagnosis such as depression, PTSD or an anxiety disorder, the treatment plan genuinely involves the partner, and sessions are billed as family therapy with the diagnosed person as the client. That is a clinical judgment rather than a billing maneuver, and it has to be true before it can be coded that way. We will tell you which situation you are in before you commit, not after a claim is denied.
Online therapy on a Cigna plan
Telehealth for behavioral health is standard on Cigna commercial plans and is typically covered at the same cost share as an office visit. For a practice spread across twelve states, the rule worth understanding is that it is not about where your therapist sits — it is about where you are physically located during the session, because your clinician has to be licensed in that state.
If you live in one state and work in another, travel for work, or are a student away from home, tell us early. It determines which of our clinicians can see you, and it is far easier to arrange before treatment starts than to unpick in the middle of it.
What we need in order to check your benefits
A benefits check takes us a few minutes and spares you the hold music. We need the member ID exactly as printed, the group number, the subscriber’s name and date of birth — which may not be yours, if you are on a parent’s or spouse’s plan — and the state you will physically be in for sessions.
What comes back is the part people actually want: whether the deductible applies to outpatient behavioral health and how much of it is left, the copay or coinsurance once it is met, and whether anything requires authorization. One honest caveat, which every practice operates under: a benefits quote is an estimate of coverage, not a guarantee of payment. It is accurate in the large majority of cases, and we will tell you promptly if a claim comes back differently.
If we turn out to be out of network on your plan
Network participation is negotiated plan by plan and state by state, so it is possible to be in network with Cigna broadly and out of network on one particular employer’s product — LocalPlus is the most frequent reason. If that happens you still have options. Many Cigna PPO plans carry out-of-network benefits that reimburse a meaningful share of the fee once an out-of-network deductible is met, and we can provide a superbill, the itemized receipt with diagnosis and procedure codes that you submit for reimbursement. HSA and FSA funds can be used for therapy as well.
It is also worth knowing that the carrier is not the only variable. If you are weighing plans, our page on Aetna therapy coverage walks through the same questions for that carrier.
Check whether your employer includes EAP sessions
A large number of Cigna members have an employee assistance program attached to their benefits without knowing it. An EAP typically provides a set number of counseling sessions per year at no cost to you, separate from your medical plan and not subject to your deductible. Three, six or eight sessions is a common allocation.
One thing to know first: New Reflections Counseling does not accept EAP authorizations, so EAP sessions would be with a provider on your EAP’s own list. If you would like to work with us, we bill your regular Cigna (Evernorth) behavioral health benefit instead, and we check that coverage free before you start.
Reading your own benefits on myCigna
If you would rather look before you call, the myCigna portal and app will show you the plan documents directly. The section you want is outpatient mental health or behavioral health, not the general specialist copay, because the two are not always the same number.
What you are looking for is three things: whether the deductible applies to outpatient behavioral health, what the copay or coinsurance is once it is satisfied, and how much of the deductible you have already met this year. That is enough to estimate a session cost within a few dollars. If the language is ambiguous — and plan documents often are — send us what you find and we will confirm it against what the insurer tells us directly.
Common questions
How much does therapy cost with Cigna?
Once any deductible is met, most people on an employer Cigna plan pay a per-session copay or a percentage of the contracted rate. Before it is met you may owe the full contracted rate, which is still lower than the self-pay fee. The honest range runs from a small copay to the full rate depending on what your employer bought, which is why we check rather than quote.
Why does Cigna keep saying Evernorth when I call about therapy?
Because Evernorth is the Cigna business that handles behavioral health. It is the right department. Your card will still say Cigna, and your therapy claims are processed correctly under that arrangement.
Does Cigna cover marriage counseling?
Usually not when relationship distress is the only presenting issue. It can be covered when one partner has a diagnosable condition and the couples work is a legitimate part of treating it. We will tell you which applies to you first.
Why is my therapy more expensive with Cigna under Evernorth?
Usually it isn’t Evernorth itself. What you pay depends on your plan’s behavioral health deductible, copay or coinsurance, which your employer chooses, and those can differ from your medical copay. Early in the year you may pay the full contracted rate until the deductible is met. We check your exact numbers before you start.
Can I use my Cigna plan for online therapy?
Yes, on virtually all commercial Cigna plans, typically at the same cost share as an in-person session. You need to be physically located in a state where your clinician holds a license at the time of the appointment.
Will my employer see that I am in therapy?
No. Your employer funds or buys the plan but does not receive your claims or your records. The insurer receives only the minimum needed to process a claim — dates of service, procedure codes and a diagnosis code. It does not receive what you talked about.
Where we work
We have offices in Wellington, Florida; White Plains, New York; Cary, North Carolina; Greenwood Village, Colorado; Greenville, South Carolina; and Princeton, New Jersey — we see clients in person only in Wellington and Cary, and by video across all twelve states we are licensed in: Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee. Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video. You can also meet our therapists and see who works in your state.
