Out-of-Network Therapist Reimbursement: How It Actually Works
You found a therapist whose profile sounds right. Then you saw the words “out of network” or “superbill” and closed the tab, because it sounded like paying full price and hoping for a refund. It doesn’t have to mean that. Out-of-network reimbursement works like this: you pay the therapist’s fee, they give you a superbill (an itemized receipt with the codes your insurer needs), you submit it, and if your plan has out-of-network benefits, it pays back part of the cost once your out-of-network deductible is met. At New Reflections Counseling you may not need any of this. Our clinicians are in network with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare (BCBS is out of network in South Carolina and in network in Illinois only with Jaime Doss; in Rhode Island only Aetna is in network so far; Tricare is out of network in Illinois and Rhode Island; and UnitedHealthcare is out of network in Illinois and not yet in network in Tennessee). So many of our clients use their in-network benefits. The steps below are for everyone else, and we provide superbills when you need one.
Not sure which route applies to you? Check your insurance or contact us. Services include individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy, teen therapy and trauma therapy and EMDR, across the states where we hold licenses (full list below).
Quick Answers
Can I get reimbursed for out-of-network therapy?
Yes, if your plan has out-of-network benefits. Many PPO and POS plans do, and most HMO and EPO plans don’t. Once your out-of-network deductible is met, your plan pays back part of each session fee.
How do I get reimbursed for out-of-network therapy?
Pay for the session, ask your therapist for a superbill, and submit it to your insurer through its member portal, app or claim form. The insurer then sends you its share, with an explanation of benefits showing how it was worked out. The four numbers below decide how much that is.
Can I submit out-of-network therapy claims myself?
Yes. When your therapist is out of network, you usually file the claim yourself, and that’s what the superbill is for. Your plan sets a filing deadline, so it’s worth submitting each month rather than saving them up.
In Network or Out of Network: Which Applies to You?
If your plan is with one of the carriers we’re in network with, we bill your plan directly. You pay your copay or coinsurance, and there’s no superbill to file. Here’s who that covers:
- Aetna, Cigna and UnitedHealthcare (its behavioral health plans run through Optum, including UMR plans): in network in every state where we practice except Georgia (in Rhode Island, only Aetna is in network so far), and UnitedHealthcare is out of network in Illinois and not yet in network in Tennessee.
- Blue Cross Blue Shield: in network everywhere except South Carolina, Rhode Island and Georgia; in Illinois, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois is in network only with Jaime Doss, LCPC.
- Tricare: in network everywhere except Illinois, Rhode Island and Georgia.
The out-of-network steps in the rest of this post apply to you when:
- your plan is with a carrier we don’t work with;
- you’re in South Carolina and your plan is Blue Cross Blue Shield, or you’re in Illinois with Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois and seeing a clinician other than Jaime Doss, or you’re in Illinois or Rhode Island and your plan is Tricare, or you’re in Rhode Island with a plan other than Aetna; or
- the benefits check shows your specific plan isn’t covered by our contract, even though the carrier’s name is on the list above.
We don’t accept Medicare or Medicaid.
The quickest way to know which group you’re in is our insurance verification form. We check your behavioral health benefits and email you what your plan reports the same day, usually within a couple of hours.
What “Out of Network” Actually Means
Every plan sorts providers into two groups. In-network providers have signed a contract with the insurer and accept its negotiated rate. Out-of-network providers haven’t, so they charge their own fee, and you’re the one who asks the plan to pay part of it back.
Some plans pay nothing toward out-of-network care. Others pay a share after you meet a separate out-of-network deductible. The plan document, or a phone call, tells you which kind you have. Nothing on your insurance card will.
The Four Numbers That Decide What You Get Back
Out-of-network math looks complicated. It comes down to four numbers from your plan, and once you have them you can estimate your real cost per session before you start.
1. Your out-of-network deductible
This is what you pay yourself each plan year before the plan starts reimbursing out-of-network care. On many plans it’s separate from your in-network deductible, and money spent on one may not count toward the other. Ask how much of it you’ve already met this year.
2. Your coinsurance
After the deductible, the plan pays a percentage and you pay the rest. That percentage varies from plan to plan, so ask for the exact figure rather than assuming.
3. The allowed amount
This is the number people miss. Your plan doesn’t pay a percentage of what your therapist charged. It pays a percentage of what it considers a reasonable fee for that service, which is called the allowed amount (or the “usual and customary rate”). Each plan sets its own, and it’s rarely published, so you have to ask.
4. Your out-of-pocket maximum
This is the ceiling on what you pay in a plan year. Once your covered spending reaches it, the plan pays covered care in full for the rest of that year. Ask whether your plan has a separate out-of-network maximum, and whether it has one at all.
How Reimbursement Works, Session by Session
Once you’re seeing an out-of-network therapist, the routine looks like this:
- You pay the therapist’s fee at the session.
- Your therapist gives you a superbill. It lists the date, the procedure (CPT) code for the type of session, a diagnosis code, the clinician’s license and tax ID details, and what you paid, and it may include the clinician’s NPI.
- You submit it to your insurer, usually through the member portal or app. Some plans still take mail or fax.
- The plan processes the claim and sends you an Explanation of Benefits (EOB). Until your deductible is met, the EOB shows the amount counted toward it. After that, it shows a reimbursement, paid by check or direct deposit.
Many people submit a month of superbills at once instead of one at a time. Some independent services will file superbills for you for a fee, which can be worth it if the paperwork is the only thing standing in the way.
What to Ask Your Insurer, Word for Word
The person who answers your insurer’s phone line will answer the question you ask. “Do I have mental health coverage?” gets a vague yes. Specific questions get specific answers.
First, know which procedure code to ask about. Psychotherapy codes are set by session length. Code 90834 covers an individual session of 38 to 52 minutes, and 90837 covers 53 minutes or more. Couples and family sessions with you present are usually billed as 90847. Our sessions run 45–50 minutes, so ask us which code will be on your superbill, and ask your insurer about that one.
Then call the member services number on your card and say something like this:
“I’m calling to check my out-of-network benefits for outpatient psychotherapy. My member ID is [number]. Can you tell me:
- What is my out-of-network deductible this plan year, and how much have I met?
- After the deductible, what percentage do you pay for out-of-network outpatient mental health care?
- What is your allowed amount for CPT code [the code from your therapist]?
- Is there a limit on sessions per year, or do I need prior authorization?
- Is there an out-of-network out-of-pocket maximum, and what is it?
- What’s the process for sending in a superbill: portal, mail or fax?
- Can I have a reference number for this call?”
Write down the date, the representative’s name and the answers. That last question matters most. If the plan later pays a claim differently from what you were told, the reference number gives you something concrete to point to when you ask for a correction.
Would you rather not make the call yourself? Fill in our insurance verification form instead. We’ll check your behavioral health benefits and email you what your plan reports, or contact us with any questions first.
Using HSA or FSA Money
You can pay for sessions with a health savings account (HSA) or flexible spending account (FSA) card. Because those accounts hold pre-tax money, paying for sessions from them lowers your real cost. How much depends on your own tax situation. This works whether we’re in network with your plan or not. Your plan administrator can confirm what your account covers.
What It Costs Here If You’re Out of Network
If we’re out of network for your plan, you pay our self-pay rate at the session and submit the superbill yourself. Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR sessions, each 45–50 minutes, and $200–$250 for an extended 90-minute individual, couples or EMDR session. Each one runs 45–50 minutes. Rates differ by session type rather than by state, so the card is the same wherever you are.
For more on paying privately, including when people choose it with insurance in hand, see therapy without insurance. Couples sessions come with their own coverage questions, which we answer in does insurance cover marriage counseling.
Common Misconceptions
“Out of network means I pay full price.” Only if your plan has no out-of-network benefits or you haven’t met the deductible yet. The four numbers above tell you which.
“My insurance card doesn’t mention mental health.” Most cards don’t. The benefits are in your full plan document, which your employer’s HR team or the insurer can send you. The phone call is usually faster.
“The therapist files the claim.” Out of network, you do: your therapist’s job is to give you an accurate superbill. When we’re in network with your plan, we bill the plan and you don’t file anything.
“My carrier is on your list, so I’m covered.” Probably, but carriers sell many plans, and the check confirms yours. It takes a few minutes of your time, and the answer usually comes the same day, often within a couple of hours.
“The reimbursement won’t be worth the paperwork.” Maybe, maybe not. Run the numbers with your plan’s actual deductible, coinsurance and allowed amount before you decide.
FAQs
Is New Reflections Counseling in network or out of network?
In network, with most plans from Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare (BCBS is out of network in South Carolina and in network in Illinois only with Jaime Doss; in Rhode Island only Aetna is in network so far; Tricare is out of network in Illinois and Rhode Island; and UnitedHealthcare is out of network in Illinois and not yet in network in Tennessee). Aetna, Cigna and UnitedHealthcare are in network in both of those states, and Tricare is in network in South Carolina. For any other plan we’re out of network, and we give you a superbill.
Will you give me a superbill if you’re out of network for my plan?
Yes. You pay the self-pay rate at each session, and we give you a superbill to send to your insurer.
How much is a session if I pay myself?
Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR sessions, each 45–50 minutes, and $200–$250 for an extended 90-minute individual, couples or EMDR session. Every session lasts 45–50 minutes, and you can pay by HSA or FSA card.
Do you accept Medicare or Medicaid?
No. Our in-network carriers are Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare (BCBS is out of network in South Carolina and in network in Illinois only with Jaime Doss; in Rhode Island only Aetna is in network so far; Tricare is out of network in Illinois and Rhode Island; and UnitedHealthcare is out of network in Illinois and not yet in network in Tennessee), and paying for yourself is always an option.
What if I’m struggling right now and the insurance part feels like too much?
Don’t let paperwork hold you up. If this is a crisis, call or text 988 (the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or call 911. If you’re not in crisis, contact us and we’ll sort out the insurance side with you.
This post explains how out-of-network benefits generally work. Your plan’s terms decide what it pays, so confirm your numbers with your insurer and keep the reference number from the call.
Where We Work
We’re licensed in 12 states: Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee. You need to be physically in one of them at the time of each session. Most of our work is by secure video. New clients can meet in person only at our Wellington, Florida office. In-person times at our Cary, North Carolina office are full right now, so new North Carolina clients start by video. All New Jersey sessions are by secure video. Each state page lists what’s offered there, and you can meet our clinicians on the therapists page.
- How Much Does Online Therapy Cost?
- Self-Pay Therapy: Rates and Options Without Insurance
- Paying for Therapy: Insurance, Out-of-Network and Self-Pay
- Does Insurance Cover Couples or Family Therapy? A State-by-State Guide
- How to Find the Right Therapist: What to Look For
- Therapy That Moves With You: Licensed in Twelve States
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
