Questions to Ask Before You Choose a Couples Therapist: A Printable Checklist
You’ve agreed to try couples therapy, and now you’re looking at a screen full of profiles that all sound alike. Here’s the short answer: before you book, ask about four things. What training does this therapist have in couples work specifically? Are they licensed in the state where each of you will be during sessions? What will it cost, and does your plan cover couples sessions at all? And how do they handle safety, secrets and individual sessions? A therapist who answers those plainly is showing you how they’ll work with you.
This checklist works for any therapist you’re considering, and you’re welcome to print it or share it. If you’d like to put these questions to us, contact us or check your insurance first. We offer couples therapy, Gottman couples counseling, emotionally focused therapy (EFT), premarital counseling and discernment counseling by secure video, with in-person couples sessions at our Wellington, Florida office (full list below).
How to Use This Checklist
You don’t need to ask every question. Pick the five or six that matter most to you and ask them by phone or email before you book. In many practices an intake coordinator answers some of them for the therapist, which is fine. If you’re choosing together, each of you can tick the questions you care about, then compare lists. The answers matter, and so does the way you get them: direct, unhurried and without a sales pitch.
Training and Approach
- ☐ What training do you have in couples therapy specifically, beyond your general license?
- ☐ Which method do you use most with couples, and why that one?
- ☐ Are you trained or certified in it, and at what level? Which organization provided the training?
- ☐ How much of your work is with couples?
- ☐ Do you work with couples who are unsure whether to stay together, or only with couples who have decided to?
“Trained” and “certified” are not the same. Trained usually means the therapist has completed coursework in a method. Certified usually means they have gone further, with more training, supervised cases and approval from the organization behind the method. Plenty of good couples therapists are trained but not certified. What matters is that they describe their level accurately and can tell you what training they’ve completed.
You’ll see a few method names come up often. In one line each:
- Gottman Method: developed by Drs. John and Julie Gottman; it works on a couple’s friendship, how they handle conflict and what they’re building together, and it usually begins with an assessment of the relationship.
- Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT): grounded in attachment research; it helps partners see the cycle they keep getting caught in and find a different way to reach each other.
- Prepare/Enrich: a questionnaire each of you completes separately, which a trained facilitator then goes through with you; it’s often used before marriage and also with established couples.
- Discernment counseling: for couples where one partner is leaning toward ending the relationship and the other wants to try; the aim is clarity about which direction to take, not repairing the relationship in those sessions.
Many therapists blend methods. That’s fine, as long as they can explain in plain words what they’ll actually do in the room.
Fit and Logistics
- ☐ Are you licensed in the state where each of us will be during sessions?
- ☐ How long are sessions, and how often do couples usually meet at the start?
- ☐ Do you have evening openings right now, not just in general?
- ☐ Do you offer sessions by video, in person, or both? Can we each join from a different place if we need to?
- ☐ How soon could we start?
- ☐ What is your cancellation policy, and is there a late-cancellation fee?
Licensure follows you, not the therapist. A therapist generally needs a license in the state where you are physically located during the session, so a couple who splits time between two states, or who will join from two places, should ask how the therapist handles that before the first session rather than after.
Cost and Insurance
- ☐ Are you in network with our plan? Whose plan would be billed?
- ☐ Do you expect our plan to cover couples sessions, and what do you need from us to check?
- ☐ If you’re out of network, will you give us a superbill to submit for reimbursement?
- ☐ What is your self-pay rate per session, and will you give us a Good Faith Estimate in writing?
- ☐ Do you bill session by session, or do you ask for a package up front?
Couples therapy is one of the services some plans don’t cover, or cover only when the sessions are treating one partner’s diagnosed condition. One call to your insurer usually settles it. Phone the member-services number on the back of the card and ask: Do I have outpatient mental health benefits with this therapist? Does my plan cover family or couples psychotherapy, billing code 90847? Is there a deductible, copay or coinsurance, and do I need prior authorization? Write down the date, the name of the person you spoke with and the call reference number.
If you’re paying for yourselves, federal rules let you ask for a Good Faith Estimate of the expected cost before you start. And a therapist should never suggest inventing a diagnosis to get a claim paid. Our longer piece on whether insurance covers marriage counseling explains why.
How Sessions Work
- ☐ What happens in the first session?
- ☐ Do you ever meet with each of us on our own? If so, what is your policy on things one of us tells you privately?
- ☐ Will you give us things to practice between sessions?
- ☐ How will we know whether it’s working? How do you check progress with us?
- ☐ What if one of us is less sure about being here than the other?
- ☐ What happens if one of us wants to stop?
The secrets question deserves a clear answer before anyone says anything in private. Therapists handle it differently. Some keep no secrets between partners, so anything said one-on-one can come up in a joint session. Some keep individual conversations confidential. Some ask that a secret affecting the relationship, such as an affair that is still going on, be shared within a set time, or they will pause the couples work. None of these is wrong. You just need to know which one you’re agreeing to.
It’s also common for one partner to arrive more hopeful than the other. A good couples therapist will treat that as information, not as a problem with the less hopeful partner, and will say so early.
Safety First: When Couples Therapy Is the Wrong First Step
Joint sessions only work when both partners can speak honestly without paying for it later. If you’re afraid of your partner, if there has been hitting, shoving, threats or forced sex, or if your partner controls your money, your phone, where you go or who you see, couples therapy is usually not a safe place to start. What you say in the room can follow you home. Individual therapy, or a conversation with a domestic violence advocate, is a safer first step.
- ☐ Do you speak with each partner privately about safety before joint sessions begin?
- ☐ What do you do if you learn there is abuse or coercive control in the relationship?
If you’re in danger right now, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential and open 24 hours a day at 1-800-799-7233. If you’re thinking about suicide or are in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
Red Flags to Notice
- They take the same partner’s side, session after session.
- They promise a result, or a set number of sessions to “fix” things.
- They can’t explain their method in plain words, or claim a certification without naming who granted it.
- They’re vague about whether they’re licensed in your state.
- They’re vague about fees, or press you to pay for a block of sessions up front.
- They brush off safety concerns, or push for joint sessions when one of you is afraid.
- They repeat something one of you said privately without having told you that was their policy.
- They steer you toward staying together, or toward splitting up, before you know what you want.
- They talk about their own relationship more than yours.
After the First Session: A Short Reflection List
Give it a day, then answer these separately before you compare notes. A first session is mostly getting to know each other, so some awkwardness is normal. Awkward isn’t the same as wrong.
- ☐ Did each of us get a real chance to talk?
- ☐ When things got heated, did the therapist slow them down?
- ☐ Do I understand what the therapist plans to do, and why?
- ☐ Even when I heard something hard, did I feel understood rather than judged?
- ☐ Did we leave with something concrete, like a question to think about or something to try?
- ☐ Would I go back for a second session?
If you both answer no to most of these, it’s fine to try someone else. If one of you says yes and the other says no, bring that into the second session. A good couples therapist will want to hear it.
Common Questions
Is a certified couples therapist better than a trained one?
Not automatically. Certification shows extra training and review in one method. Fit, honesty about limits and how the therapist handles conflict in the room matter at least as much. Ask what training they’ve completed and judge the answer on its plainness.
Can we do couples therapy online if we’re in different states?
Sometimes. The therapist usually needs to be licensed in each state where one of you is located during the session. Ask that question directly before you book.
What if my partner won’t come?
You can still start on your own. Individual therapy can help you get clear on what you want and how you respond when things get tense. Some couples therapists will also meet with one partner first; ask whether that’s an option and how they’d bring the other partner in later.
How We Answer These at New Reflections Counseling
Since you may ask us, here are our answers in brief. Our couples clinicians draw on skills from the Gottman Method, and we’ll tell you each clinician’s training level plainly, trained or certified. Emotionally focused therapy is offered by video in ten states, and we offer premarital and discernment counseling too. Sessions are 45–50 minutes. Couples meet with us by secure video in every state we serve, and in person at our Wellington, Florida office. We’ll check your benefits free before you book, and we’re glad to answer any question on this list first. If it turns out we’re not the right fit, we’ll say so.
Where We Work
We see clients by secure video in Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee, and in person at our Wellington, Florida office. Couples therapy is offered in every state on this list. You must be located in one of these states during each session. In-person times at our Cary, North Carolina office are full right now, so new North Carolina clients start by video, and all New Jersey sessions are by secure video. Meet the clinicians on our therapists page.
- How to Find the Right Therapist: What to Look For and What to Ask
- Does Couples Therapy Work? What the Research Says, and What Makes It Help
- Does Insurance Cover Couples or Family Therapy? A State-by-State Guide
- The 7 Principles of the Gottman Method, Explained
- Stonewalling and the Silent Treatment: Why Your Partner Shuts Down
- Secure Attachment in Relationships: What Emotional Safety Looks Like
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
