You have had the conversation four times this year. It ends the same way: one of you saying you cannot keep doing this, the other saying tell me what you want me to change, and both of you going to bed without an answer. Neither of you has packed a bag. Neither of you has booked a therapist either, because you are not sure what you would be booking it for.
If that is where you are, we can help you work out the direction before you commit to anything. Get in touch or check your insurance. We offer couples therapy, Emotionally Focused Therapy, Gottman Method work and individual therapy by secure telehealth in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Colorado, and in five more states.
When You Are Not Both in the Same Place
Couples therapy assumes something that is often not true: that both people want the relationship to work and are asking how. When one of you is already halfway out of the door and the other is holding on, that assumption breaks. The person leaning out sits through sessions that feel like being talked back into something. The person leaning in works hard and cannot understand why it is not landing. Six months later nothing has moved and both feel worse.
Therapists call this a mixed-agenda couple, and it is extremely common. It is also the situation that standard couples work handles worst.
What Discernment Counseling Is
Discernment counseling was developed by Bill Doherty at the University of Minnesota specifically for couples in that position. It is not couples therapy and it is not a soft launch into couples therapy. Its only goal is to help you reach a clear, confident decision about direction, with a proper understanding of what happened to your relationship and what each of you contributed.
It is deliberately focused, and it ends when you have reached a decision. Nobody is asked to work on the marriage during it. You are not asked to try harder, communicate better or forgive anything. You are asked to understand it well enough to choose.
The Three Paths
There are only three outcomes, and they are named out loud in the first session so nobody is being steered without knowing it.
One: stay as you are. Change nothing for now. This sounds like a non-answer and is sometimes the honest one, particularly where there is a reason to wait — a health crisis, a child mid-exams, a job ending in six months.
Two: separate. Move toward separation or divorce, with the decision made deliberately rather than by attrition.
Three: commit to full-effort couples therapy, with separation off the table for an agreed period. Not “let us try counseling and see”. A defined stretch in which both people are genuinely in, and the exit is not available as a background option. That distinction is what makes this stretch work when the previous attempts did not.
Path three is the outcome discernment counseling most often produces, but it is not the outcome it is designed to produce. A counselor steering you toward it would be doing the work badly.
What Happens in the Room
The shape is unusual, and it is built around the decision. Sessions run 45–50 minutes, and much of the time is spent with each of you individually rather than together. You start joined, split for the substantial part, and come back together at the end so each of you hears a summary of what the other has been working on.
The two conversations are different by design. With the person leaning out, the work is on whether anything could change their mind, and on their own part in how things got here — a question that is easy to skip when you have already decided. With the person leaning in, the work is often on stopping the pursuit, because pursuing harder is usually making the leaving more attractive, and on what they would want for themselves either way.
At the end of each session both of you are asked the same thing: which of the three paths are you leaning toward today, and what would need to be true to move you? That is the whole method. It sounds simple and it is uncomfortable, because it does not let either person stay vague.
Who Discernment Counseling Is Not For
Three situations where it is the wrong tool, and we will say so rather than book you in.
Where the decision is already final. If one of you has definitely decided to leave and is looking for a gentler way to deliver it, this is not that. It uses the other person’s hope as a cushion, and it is unkind. What you want there is help having the conversation, which is different work.
Where there is coercive control or abuse. Discernment counseling assumes two people who are both free to choose. If one partner is frightened of the other, if there is physical violence, if money, immigration status or access to the children is being used as leverage, then joint work of any kind can be unsafe, and individual support comes first. Our page on emotional abuse covers what that looks like when it is not physical. If you are in immediate danger, call 911, or the National Domestic Violence Hotline on 1-800-799-7233.
Where both of you are already committed. If you both want this to work and are asking how, you do not need discernment. You need couples therapy, and you should start there.
Separation Counseling: Doing It On Purpose
Most separations are not decided. They happen. Someone stays at their mother’s for a couple of weeks, then it is a month, then there is a lease, and eighteen months later two people who never chose this are living apart and are not sure how it happened.
Separation counseling is the alternative: making it a structured decision with terms both people have agreed, whether it ends in reconciliation or in divorce. It is the same work either way, because an unstructured separation is bad preparation for both outcomes.
A Trial Separation Needs Terms
The difference between a trial separation that clarifies something and one that quietly becomes a divorce is whether anyone wrote down what it is for. The terms that matter, and that couples reliably avoid discussing until they become fights:
How long. An end date, usually three to six months, at which you sit down and review. Open-ended separations drift by default.
What it is for. Space to calm down is not a purpose. What would each of you be trying to find out?
Contact. How often, in what form, and who initiates. Vagueness here produces the most pain, because one person is waiting for a text that the other did not know they were meant to send.
Whether either of you will see other people. Ask it explicitly. Assuming the answer is how a trial separation becomes an ending.
The children. What they are told, by whom, together, and what the arrangement is. Children handle a clear temporary arrangement far better than an atmosphere nobody explains.
Money. Who pays what, from which account, for how long.
Whether you are both in therapy during it. A separation with no work in it is just distance, and distance on its own changes nothing.
In-House Separation
Plenty of couples separate without anyone moving out, because of money, children, immigration status or a housing market. It can work, and it needs more explicit terms than a physical separation rather than fewer, because the ordinary domestic cues no longer tell you where you stand.
Sleeping arrangements, meals, who is responsible for what, what you say to visitors, whether you still do the things couples do. Left unspoken, one person is generally operating as though the relationship is paused and the other as though it is over, and the gap between those does damage.
Emotional Separation While Still Together
The most common version has no legal or physical component at all. You live in the same house, run the same logistics and have separated internally: no longer confiding, no longer curious, functioning smoothly and alone.
This is the state most likely to be left for years, because nothing forces the issue. There is no crisis, no event, nothing anybody would recognize as a problem from outside. We have written about that specifically in Emotional Distance in a Relationship, and about rebuilding from it in how to build emotional intimacy.
If the Decision Is to Separate
Then the work changes rather than stopping. How you separate shapes years afterward, particularly with children, and couples who use therapy through the ending generally co-parent better than those who stop at the decision.
What it covers: how and when you tell the children, and the version you both agree to say; how you talk to each other when logistics have to be handled; managing the pull to relitigate the whole marriage every time a practical question comes up; and grief, which arrives even for the person who chose it and is often a shock to them. Our guides to healing after a breakup and divorce recovery pick that up.
If the Decision Is to Stay
The commitment is not a formality, and it is not the same as the counseling you may have tried before. The difference is that leaving is genuinely off the table for that period, which changes what both people can risk saying.
Structurally we would usually work with Emotionally Focused Therapy where the problem is the cycle underneath the arguments, or Gottman Method work where the pressing problem is how the two of you fight. Where a betrayal is in the history, that has its own sequence and it is slower than either partner wants.
Common Questions
How is discernment counseling different from couples therapy?
Couples therapy tries to improve the relationship and assumes you both want that. Discernment counseling makes no attempt to improve anything. It is aimed only at a decision, and it is built for the situation where one of you is not sure they want to be there at all.
How many sessions does it take?
There is no set number of sessions. It ends when you have both reached a clear decision. If it drifts into general couples work, it has turned into something else and should be renamed rather than continued.
My partner will not come. Can I do this alone?
Not discernment counseling itself, which needs both people. But the same question is workable in individual therapy, and it is a good use of it. Deciding whether to stay is a legitimate thing to bring to a therapist on your own, and one person changing often shifts what the other is responding to.
Does a trial separation usually end in divorce?
Often, and the honest reason is that most trial separations have no terms, no end date and no therapy in them, so nothing is being tested. A structured separation with an agreed purpose is a genuinely different thing from moving out to get some peace.
Is it too late if we have been unhappy for years?
Duration matters less than whether both people still want it different. Long-unhappy couples do recover. What predicts a poor outcome is contempt, and even contempt is workable if both people are willing to look at it.
Can we do this over video?
Yes. Discernment counseling works well by telehealth, and the individual portions arguably work better, because each person is in their own space rather than waiting in a corridor.
Discernment Counseling in South Carolina
We offer discernment counseling to couples across South Carolina, by secure video statewide — Columbia and the Midlands, Charleston and the Lowcountry, Spartanburg, Rock Hill and the Upstate towns around Greenville.
South Carolina has a one-year separation requirement for a no-fault divorce, and that single fact changes what this work is for here. A couple in this state is often deciding whether to start a clock, not whether to file next month. We are not attorneys and nothing here is legal advice — check the current requirements with a South Carolina family lawyer before you rely on them. But it is worth saying plainly that the decision in front of most couples who call us from this state is bigger and slower than “should we separate,” and time spent getting it right is cheap against a year of drifting.
Telehealth matters more than usual for this particular work. Discernment counseling involves individual conversations with each partner as well as joint ones, and couples who are already living apart, or who do not want to be seen walking into the same building, find video easier to commit to. Sessions run 45–50 minutes at $175 out of pocket, and there is no set number of sessions; the process ends when you reach a decision.
If the decision is to stay and work on it, that work usually continues as couples therapy: couples counseling in Greenville, couples therapy in Columbia, or by video anywhere in the state through our South Carolina practice.
Discernment Counseling in Chicago and Illinois
In Illinois, discernment counseling is with Lisa Abrotsky, LMFT, by secure video, whether you live in Chicago, the suburbs or downstate. There are no in-person sessions in Illinois. We are in network with Aetna and Cigna in Illinois, though many plans don’t cover couples work; if yours doesn’t, self-pay is $175 per 45–50 minute session. For the clinicians and plans we have there, see our page on online therapy in Illinois.
Where We Work
We see clients by secure telehealth in Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee. Couples work is offered in every state on that list, including Rhode Island with LaShaunda Miles, LCSW. Discernment counseling is offered in every state on that list except Rhode Island. In-person appointments are in Wellington, Florida, and Cary, North Carolina. Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video. You can see our clinicians and the states each is licensed in, or check your insurance before you call.
• Emotional Distance in a Relationship: When You Feel Alone Together
• How to Build Emotional Intimacy in a Relationship
• Emotional Safety in a Relationship: What Secure Attachment Looks Like
• How to Become Emotionally Available
• Grieving a Relationship Breakup: How to Heal After Heartbreak
• Divorce Recovery Therapist & Couples Therapy
