Gottman’s Four Horsemen: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness and Stonewalling
You asked whether the electric bill got paid. Ten minutes later you are arguing about his mother, the way you sigh, and the dinner reservation you forgot three years ago, and neither of you can say how you got there. If someone has told you this sounds like “the four horsemen,” here is the short answer. The four horsemen are four habits in an argument that psychologist John Gottman found, in his research with couples, tend to show up when a relationship is in trouble: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Each has an antidote: a gentle start-up instead of criticism, appreciation and respect instead of contempt, taking responsibility instead of defensiveness, and calming your body down instead of stonewalling. Every couple slips into all four sometimes; what matters is whether they have become your normal way of talking.
Want help changing how the two of you argue? You can request an appointment or check your insurance first. We work on these patterns in couples therapy and Gottman couples counseling, through emotionally focused therapy (EFT), and in individual therapy if your partner isn’t ready to come. Sessions are by secure video, or in person in Wellington, Florida (full list below).
Where the four horsemen come from
John Gottman is a psychologist who, with his wife and colleague Julie Gottman, developed the Gottman Method of couples therapy, largely out of his research. Couples came into a lab and talked through a real disagreement while researchers recorded what they said and how their bodies reacted, and many of those couples were followed for years afterward. Four ways of arguing kept turning up in the relationships that ended or grew unhappy. Gottman named them after the four horsemen of the apocalypse, as a warning that trouble is on its way, and described them for general readers in his 1994 book Why Marriages Succeed or Fail.
You may have seen a figure quoted for how accurately this research predicted divorce. We leave it out here. Those numbers come from particular studies of particular groups of couples, and none of them can tell you what will happen to yours. The useful part is the patterns themselves, because they are specific enough to notice in the moment and change.
Criticism, and the gentle start-up
A complaint is about something that happened. Criticism is about who your partner is. “You said you’d call the plumber, and the sink is still leaking” is a complaint. “You can’t follow through on anything” is criticism. Words like “always” and “never” are usually the giveaway, and so is a question that is really an accusation, such as “What is wrong with you?”
Criticism is hard to hear without defending yourself, so it often starts the whole chain. The antidote Gottman describes is a gentle start-up: say what you feel, about one specific situation, and what you need. Leave out the verdict on your partner’s character. “I’m stressed about the leak, and I need us to pick a day to get someone out here” gives your partner something they can say yes to.
Contempt, and a habit of appreciation
Contempt is criticism delivered from above. It sounds like sarcasm, mockery, name-calling, or correcting your partner’s grammar in the middle of a fight. It also shows up in the body: the eye-roll, the scoff, the laugh that isn’t really a laugh. Underneath, contempt says, “I am better than you.”
Gottman treats contempt as the most damaging of the four. It tends to grow from negative thoughts about your partner that have gone unspoken or unresolved for a long time, until they harden into a judgment about who that person is.
The antidote is to rebuild a habit of appreciation and respect. That means noticing, on purpose, what your partner does right and saying it out loud, and, when you are angry, talking about your own feelings and needs instead of your partner’s flaws. If appreciation feels out of reach right now, that is worth bringing to a couples therapist, because it often means the hurt underneath has been building for a while.
Defensiveness, and taking responsibility
Defensiveness is the most understandable of the four. When you feel attacked, you protect yourself. It can sound like an excuse (“Traffic was terrible, what did you want me to do?”), a counterattack (“Well, you forgot the school forms last week”), or the innocent-victim stance (“I can’t do anything right in this house”).
The trouble is what it tells your partner: the problem is yours, not mine. So they push harder, and you defend harder. The antidote is taking responsibility, even for a small part. “You’re right, I said I’d leave early and I didn’t. I’m sorry you were waiting.” You don’t have to agree with everything your partner said to own the piece that is yours, and that one sentence often lowers the temperature more than any explanation would.
Stonewalling, and calming your body
Stonewalling is shutting down in the middle of a conversation: going quiet, looking away, giving short answers or none, walking out of the room. To the partner on the other side, it can look like not caring. Very often, though, the person who stonewalls is overwhelmed. Gottman calls this flooding, when your heart is racing and your body treats the argument like a threat. In that state, listening well is close to impossible.
The antidote is what Gottman calls physiological self-soothing, a formal way of saying: stop, settle your body, then come back. Tell your partner you need a break and when you will return, so the pause doesn’t feel like being left. Use the time to calm down rather than to rehearse your side, and come back when you said you would.
We cover flooding in couples counseling for communication problems, how stonewalling differs from the silent treatment in its own post, and repair in rupture and repair.
How the four feed each other
The horsemen rarely ride alone. Criticism invites defensiveness. Defensiveness feels like being dismissed, which can turn frustration into contempt. When criticism and contempt keep coming, one partner may start to stonewall, which the other feels as being shut out, so they criticize more. In Gottman’s account, stonewalling often arrives last, after the others have been around for a while.
That is why it helps to work on your own horseman before your partner’s. When either of you changes your part of the loop, the whole thing slows down.
The four horsemen and their antidotes at a glance
| Horseman | What it can sound like | Antidote | What to try instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Criticism | “You can’t follow through on anything.” | Gentle start-up | “I’m worried about the leak. Can we pick a day to call someone?” |
| Contempt | Sarcasm, eye-rolling, “Wow, very mature.” | Appreciation and respect | Name one specific thing you value, and talk about your feelings, not their flaws. |
| Defensiveness | “Well, you forgot the school forms last week.” | Taking responsibility | “You’re right, I didn’t leave on time. I’m sorry.” |
| Stonewalling | Silence, looking away, leaving mid-sentence | Calming your body | “I’m too worked up to talk this through right now. Can we try again at eight?” |
If you recognize most of that table, you don’t have to sort it out alone. Get in touch or check your insurance first. You do not need a diagnosis or a referral to start.
Using the names without turning them into weapons
Once you learn these words, it’s tempting to aim them at your partner: “That’s contempt.” “You’re stonewalling again.” Said in the middle of a fight, the label usually lands as one more criticism, and the argument shifts to whether the label is fair.
A better use comes later, when things are calm. Each of you names the horseman you reach for most, since most people have a favorite. Then agree on a light signal, such as a hand flat on the table, that means “I think we’re sliding.” Either of you can use it, and using it doesn’t score a point.
How couples therapy works with the four horsemen
In couples therapy you don’t just talk about the horsemen. You meet them in the room. A therapist slows down a real disagreement so you can both see where criticism opened it, where the defending began and where one of you went quiet. Then you practice the antidotes there, with someone coaching, and try them at home between sessions.
Our couples clinicians draw on skills from the Gottman Method. Lisa Abrotsky, LMFT, our founder, is trained in the Gottman Method at Levels 1 and 2 (trained, not certified). New Reflections Counseling is not affiliated with The Gottman Institute. Separately, emotionally focused therapy (EFT), which looks closely at the cycle a couple gets caught in, is offered by secure video in ten of our states. There is no set number of sessions.
If one of you is unsure about staying, discernment counseling is built for that question. If your partner won’t come, individual therapy can still change your half of the pattern. Engaged couples can learn the antidotes early in premarital counseling. In New Jersey, all sessions are by secure video.
When it isn’t a communication problem
Everything above assumes two people who sometimes argue badly but are safe with each other. Contempt can also be part of something else: a partner who belittles you constantly, controls your money or who you see, threatens you, or hurts you physically. Better wording won’t fix that, and joint couples sessions are not the right place to start. Your own support and a plan for your safety come first. Our post on emotional abuse examples can help you sort out what you are living with.
If you are in danger right now, call 911. You can call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233; it is free and confidential. If you or your partner are in crisis or thinking about suicide, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, at any hour.
Common questions
Which of the four horsemen is the worst?
Gottman describes contempt as the most damaging, because it carries disgust and superiority, not just frustration. But the four travel together, so easing one usually eases the others.
Do the four horsemen mean we’re headed for divorce?
No. They are warning signs, not a verdict. Most couples use all four at times. They matter most when they have become the usual tone between you, and even then they are habits, which means they can be worked on.
Is stonewalling the same as the silent treatment?
Not quite. Stonewalling is usually a shutdown when someone is overwhelmed. The silent treatment is often deliberate, used to punish or pressure. When silence is part of a wider pattern of control, it belongs with the safety information above, not with communication skills. Our post on stonewalling vs. the silent treatment covers the difference in full.
How much does couples therapy cost?
Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR. Sessions are 45–50 minutes. We are in network with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare (Optum), Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare, though the list varies by state. Whether a plan covers couples sessions varies too, so check your insurance. The benefits check is free, and we will email you the results within 1–2 business days. More detail is in does insurance cover marriage counseling?
Where we work
Our clinicians hold licenses in Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee, and you need to be in one of those states at the time of each session. Couples sessions are by secure video in all of them, and in person in Wellington, Florida. Our Cary, North Carolina office has no in-person openings now, so new clients there begin by secure video. To start, contact us or check your insurance, and meet our therapists.
- The 7 principles of the Gottman Method, explained
- Couples who argue or stop talking
- Rupture and repair in a relationship
- Does couples therapy work?
- Signs of a toxic marriage
- Feeling alone together as a couple
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
