EMDR Therapy in Chicago: Processing Trauma That Talking Has Not Reached
She kept saying she was fine, and by most measures she was — working, parenting, getting through the day. But the L train still made her chest tighten at a particular stop, and certain conversations ended with her leaving the room before she knew why. She had done therapy before, talked through everything carefully and understood all of it, and the reactions had not moved. That is the specific pattern EMDR was designed for: when understanding is not the problem but the body has not caught up.
To begin, contact us or check your insurance. EMDR in Illinois is with Lisa Abrotsky, LMFT, or LaShaunda Miles, LCSW, by secure video. We offer EMDR by secure video only, across Illinois, Colorado, Florida, New Jersey, New York and South Carolina, plus five more states, though not Georgia — full list below. It sits alongside trauma therapy, couples counseling, individual therapy and depression counseling, which we offer by telehealth across Illinois, and by video in Colorado, Florida, New Jersey, New York and South Carolina, with in-person sessions for non-EMDR work in Wellington, Florida, and Cary, North Carolina. Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video.
Why Knowing What Happened Has Not Fixed the Reaction
Plenty of people arrive at our practice having already done good work in therapy. They can name the event, trace the pattern, explain why they react the way they do. None of that is wrong. The problem is that the nervous system operates on a different schedule from the thinking mind, and insight does not automatically reach it.
The working model behind EMDR is that traumatic memories are stored differently from ordinary ones. An ordinary memory fades and settles into the past. A traumatic one can stay live — held with the original sensations, the original emotions and the original conclusions about yourself still attached, ready to fire at full intensity when something in the present resembles the original situation closely enough. A sound, a smell, a tone of voice, a stretch of road.
EMDR pairs brief, focused attention on that memory with bilateral stimulation — most often guided eye movements. What tends to shift is not the content of the memory but its charge. People describe the memory afterward as further away, smaller, or simply finished. The facts remain. The grip loosens.
How the Process Works
EMDR follows an eight-phase protocol, and that structure exists for good reason. Reprocessing does not start in the first session. The opening phases cover history, treatment planning and preparation — developing reliable ways to bring your own arousal down and establishing what happens if something surfaces between sessions or at an inconvenient moment.
Preparation is the phase most people underestimate and the one that determines whether the reprocessing goes well. Only once that groundwork is solid does the active reprocessing begin. A reprocessing session runs 45–50 minutes, like every session here, and we plan it so the work is not left half-finished.
Hear EMDR Explained by Our Founder
Lisa Abrotsky, LMFT, NRC’s founder, joined Lisa Tickel on the How Adults Do Relationships podcast to talk about what EMDR is, how it differs from talk therapy, and why trauma so often shows up sideways in everyday life. If you’re curious about EMDR but not sure it’s for you, this is a calm place to start.
Watch on YouTube (52 minutes)
What Brings Chicago Clients to EMDR
Chicago carries its own patterns. Car accidents on the expressways — the Dan Ryan, the Eisenhower, the Kennedy — are a common starting point, and the city’s traffic means the reminder is daily rather than avoidable. People describe doing well until they have to merge onto the same stretch again, and then everything is back.
Gun violence and its proximity are another. You do not have to have been the person it happened to. Hearing it, witnessing it, knowing the person it happened to, growing up in a neighborhood where it was ordinary — each of these can produce the same nervous-system imprint. The body learned that alertness was survival, and it has not received the message that the circumstances changed.
We also see childhood trauma resurfacing once someone becomes a parent, medical trauma from a difficult birth or hospital stay, assault, sudden loss, and the particular kind of workplace stress that accumulates in first responders, nurses and teachers until one event tips the balance. Many people who call do not use the word trauma at all. They describe anxiety that does not respond to the usual tools, anger that shows up faster than it should, or a numbness that has settled in and will not lift.
The City That Never Stops Moving and the Cost of Keeping Up
Chicago is a city of long commutes, demanding jobs and high expectations about what keeping it together looks like. People put off starting therapy not because they do not know something is wrong but because there is never a clear opening. The pace does not make it easy, and the winters do not help — shorter days, fewer hours outside, the kind of cold that makes leaving the house feel like an accomplishment.
That delay has a cost. Traumatic memories that stay unprocessed do not stay the same size; they tend to attract other material. A single event can expand into a general watchfulness, a shortened temper, a retreat from the things that used to matter. Starting sooner rather than later is not urgency for its own sake. It is that earlier is usually simpler.
Telehealth makes starting possible without rearranging your commute or your childcare. You do not need to get to a specific office by a specific time on the CTA. You need a private room and a screen for fifty minutes, and that is an easier problem to solve.
Anger, Numbness and Other Things That Do Not Look Like Trauma
Anger is one of the least understood presentations of trauma and one of the most common reasons people in Chicago look for help without ever framing it that way. The pattern is recognizable: a reaction out of proportion to the trigger, arriving before you have had a chance to think, followed by shame about it. People describe going from calm to furious with nothing in between.
Often it is not an anger problem in the way people assume. It is a threat response that learned, in some earlier situation, that speed was more important than accuracy. Teaching calming techniques alone tends to disappoint — the techniques work in the moment but nothing underneath changes. Reprocessing the earlier material can shift the threshold itself, so there is more room between the trigger and the reaction.
Emotional numbness is a different version of the same mechanism. Where anger is the system stuck on high, numbness is the system that decided shutting down was safer than feeling. People describe it as being present but not really there, watching their own life from behind glass. Depression is sometimes what brings them in, but the depression is sitting on top of something older. EMDR can reach underneath it.
What the First Appointment Looks Like
A 45–50 minute session, mostly conversation, and no reprocessing. We want to know what is bringing you now rather than a year ago, what you have tried before and how it went, what happens physically when the subject comes up, and the practical shape of your week — sleep, work, who is at home, whether you feel safe where you live.
Some of that is routine. Some of it is specifically about whether reprocessing is a good idea to begin this month. You will leave with a plan rather than a diagnosis: whether EMDR looks like the right tool, roughly how much preparation we expect to need, and what we would do first if it is not.
How EMDR Fits Alongside Other Work
EMDR is rarely the only thing happening. It sits inside the wider work — the week you are actually having, the relationship you are navigating, the sleep you are not getting. In practice this means reprocessing sessions are interleaved with ordinary therapy sessions, and we move between them according to what the month requires rather than a fixed schedule.
If something urgent arrives — a crisis at work, a relationship rupture, a week where you are simply too depleted — we deal with that first and return to the reprocessing when conditions allow. The protocol is structured, but it is not a conveyor belt.
When We Would Not Start With EMDR
Reprocessing is not the right opening move for everyone, and it is fairer to say so up front. If you are in crisis, in an unsafe living situation, or using substances in a way that is currently doing the work of holding you together, we stabilize first. The same applies during an acute upheaval — a separation in progress, a housing problem, a family emergency.
There is no benefit to reprocessing on schedule while the rest of your life is in motion. And occasionally the honest answer is that a different approach fits better. We would rather tell you that than deliver the treatment you came asking for when something else is what you need.
Telehealth Across Illinois
EMDR in Illinois is by secure video, and so are all our other Illinois services. That means you can work with us from anywhere in the state — Chicago, the suburbs, downstate — without needing to reach a specific office. For EMDR specifically, secure video is the only way we offer it, here and in every other state, and it works well for most people and most phases of the work. Whether it suits your particular situation is a clinical decision we make together rather than an assumption.
All Illinois EMDR sessions are by secure video. For many Illinois clients, the convenience of telehealth more than compensates, especially given Chicago commute times and winter weather.
Cost and Insurance
In Illinois we’re in network with Aetna and Cigna. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois is in network only for sessions with Jaime Doss, LCPC, who doesn’t provide EMDR, so it is out of network for EMDR; Blue Cross Blue Shield of Illinois members can see Jaime for other therapy, such as trauma-focused or couples work. For EMDR, or any plan that is out of network, you can still use out-of-network benefits: we give you a superbill after every session (see our out-of-network reimbursement guide). We do not accept Medicare or Medicaid. Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR. All sessions, including EMDR, are 45–50 minutes.
Send your plan details through our insurance verification form and we will check what your coverage looks like before the first appointment.
Common Questions
How long does a course of EMDR take?
There is no set number of sessions. A single recent incident usually moves faster than trauma that ran for years, mostly because the preparation phase takes longer. We will give you a realistic range once we know what we are working with, not before.
Do I have to describe everything that happened?
No. You need to be able to hold the memory in mind. Narrating it in sequence is not required, which is why EMDR is often workable for people who have found talk therapy impossible on this particular subject.
What if something comes up between sessions?
Expect some of that, especially early in the reprocessing phase. You will leave the preparation phase with specific tools and a clear instruction about when to call rather than wait. Rough weeks are pacing information, not failure.
Can I do EMDR and couples therapy at the same time?
Often yes, and sometimes that is the right structure — individual reprocessing running alongside couples sessions, with each piece kept in its own room. We will be clear about which is which.
Does EMDR work over telehealth?
For many people, yes, and it is the only way we offer EMDR. It is not automatically right for everyone or for every phase, and we will give you a straight answer about whether it suits your situation rather than starting anyway.
If you are in crisis, call or text 988. The 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline is available around the clock.
Where We Work
We are licensed in twelve states: Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee. See our therapists page for who holds which license.
- What is EMDR therapy and how it works
- Trauma therapy in Chicago
- Depression counseling in Chicago
- Anxiety therapy in Chicago
- How to deal with triggers from trauma
- Postpartum therapy in Chicago
- Online teen therapy in Illinois
Ready to Begin?
If you have already done the talking and the reaction has not moved, that is the specific gap EMDR was built for. A first appointment is 45–50 minutes of conversation with no reprocessing, and you leave with a plan rather than a diagnosis.
Contact us to book a first appointment, or check your insurance coverage first if you would rather know the cost before you commit.
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
