Do Affirmations Actually Work? When They Help and When They Backfire
If you have stood in front of a mirror telling yourself you are worthy and felt the sentence curdle on the way out, you are not doing it wrong. That reaction is well documented, and it is more common in exactly the people affirmations are usually recommended to. If this is something you want support with, you can browse our full range of services or verify your insurance coverage before scheduling.
To begin, contact us or check your insurance. We offer individual therapy, couples therapy and family therapy — by telehealth across twelve states, including Florida, New York, New Jersey, North Carolina and South Carolina.
We see clients by secure telehealth in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Colorado, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee, with in-person appointments available in Wellington, Florida, and Cary, North Carolina (Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video).
Said it in the mirror and believed it less each time? New Reflections Counseling offers individual therapy for self-esteem, anxiety and depression, working on what the sentence is arguing with rather than the sentence.
Affirmations are not useless. They are just far more specific in what they do than the way they are usually sold, and for one group of people they reliably make things worse before they make anything better.
The Finding Most Affirmation Advice Leaves Out
In 2009 a study published in Psychological Science asked people to repeat the statement “I am a lovable person” and measured how they felt afterward. People who already had high self-esteem felt slightly better. People with low self-esteem felt worse than a control group who did nothing at all.
The explanation is straightforward once you see it. A statement far outside what you currently believe does not get absorbed; it gets argued with. Say “I am confident” to a mind holding a great deal of evidence to the contrary and the mind does what minds do — it produces the evidence. You end up more aware of the gap than you were before you spoke.
This is a single line of research rather than the last word, and later work has added nuance about wording, framing and context. But the core observation has held up well enough to be worth knowing before you start, particularly because the people most likely to be handed a list of affirmations for self-esteem are the ones the effect applies to.
When Affirmations Do Help
The versions that work tend to share a shape. They are believable, they are about values rather than traits, and they are used before a difficult thing rather than instead of it.
- Values affirmation. Writing briefly about something that genuinely matters to you — family, craft, fairness — before a stressful task. This is the best-supported form and it does not require claiming anything about yourself.
- Process over verdict. “I can get through this hour” is usable. “I am unshakeable” is not.
- Present rather than aspirational. “I am allowed to find this hard” lands where “I am thriving” does not.
- Used as preparation. Before the meeting, the call, the appointment — not as a substitute for going.
The common thread is that none of these require you to assert something you do not believe. They lower the stakes rather than raising the claim.
When They Backfire
- The gap is too wide. If the statement is a long way from your actual view, repeating it measures the distance rather than closing it.
- It becomes a way to avoid the feeling. Affirming your way past grief, anger or a legitimate problem postpones it and adds a layer of failing-at-positivity on top.
- It turns into another performance. Doing them correctly, doing them daily, doing enough of them — particularly for people already prone to perfectionism.
- It replaces action. Twenty minutes affirming abundance is twenty minutes not spent on the thing generating the worry.
- Used for depression as treatment. Depression is not a belief problem that better sentences correct, and framing it that way quietly makes it the person’s fault for not affirming hard enough.
What Works Better for the Same Problem
Most people reaching for affirmations want one of three things: to feel less anxious, to think about themselves less harshly, or to be able to do something they are avoiding. Each has a better tool.
For the harsh inner voice, the useful move is not contradiction but accuracy. Cognitive work asks what the evidence actually is, on both sides, rather than asserting the opposite. That is the core of CBT for anxiety and depression, and it works precisely because it does not ask you to believe something you do not.
For anxiety in the moment, the body responds faster than the sentence does. Slow breathing and grounding shift the physiology directly, which is covered in how to calm your nervous system.
For self-esteem, the evidence points to behavior rather than declaration. Doing a difficult thing and surviving it updates self-view faster than any statement about self-view. Our page on self-esteem counseling covers how that work goes.
For self-criticism specifically, self-compassion has better support than self-esteem work. The question is not “am I good” but “how would I speak to someone I liked who was in this position”, which most people can answer even on a bad day.
A Version That Usually Survives Contact
If you want to keep something like a practice, the reframe that works for most people is to stop asserting and start allowing.
- “I am allowed to find this hard.”
- “This feeling will pass, even if I cannot feel that yet.”
- “I do not have to be sure to begin.”
- “I can do this badly and it still counts.”
- “What I am feeling makes sense given what happened.”
- Individual therapy
None of these claim anything you would have to defend. They are true on your worst day, which is the only test that matters, because a statement you cannot believe on a bad day is not available on a bad day.
Common Questions
Do affirmations work for anxiety? Modestly, and mostly as preparation rather than as a rescue technique. When anxiety is already high, physiological approaches work faster than verbal ones.
Do affirmations help depression? Not as treatment. They may sit alongside it, but depression responds to therapy, behavioral change and, for some people, medication — not to better sentences.
Why do affirmations make me feel worse? Most likely the gap between the statement and your current view is too wide, so the statement prompts counter-evidence. Smaller, believable statements avoid this.
How long before they work? If a phrase still feels false after a few weeks, that is information rather than failure. Change the phrase to something you can actually agree with.
Is there a right way to do them? Believable, specific, present tense, and used before something hard rather than instead of it. Beyond that the format matters less than whether you can say it without arguing.
When It Is Worth Talking to Someone
If the voice you are trying to affirm over is relentless, if it started early, or if no amount of rephrasing gets past it, the problem is usually not the wording. Something is being maintained underneath, and that is workable but not by yourself in a mirror.
Where We Can See You
We see clients by secure telehealth in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Colorado, Connecticut, Georgia, Illinois, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina and Tennessee, with in-person appointments available in Wellington, Florida, and Cary, North Carolina (Cary’s in-person times are currently full, so new clients there start by video).
You can check your insurance or get in touch and we will help you work out where to start.
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
Where We Work
You can read about the clinicians you would be working with on our therapists page.
