Shame vs Guilt: What’s the Difference, and What Helps
You snapped at your kid over spilled juice, and an hour later two voices are still arguing in your head. One says, “That wasn’t fair. I should apologize.” The other says, “This is who you are. You’re a terrible parent.” (An illustration, not a real client.)
Want to talk it through with someone? Contact us or check your insurance. We offer individual therapy by secure video in all twelve states we serve, along with Internal Family Systems (IFS), trauma therapy and couples therapy. See the full list below.
The short answer: guilt is feeling bad about something you did. Shame is feeling bad about who you are. Guilt says “I did something bad,” and it tends to push you toward fixing it. Shame says “I am bad,” and it tends to push you toward hiding, defending yourself or lashing out. Both hurt, but they lead in very different directions.
If shame has you thinking about ending your life or hurting yourself, call or text 988 now to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, at any hour. If you are in immediate danger, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room.
What shame is
Shame is the painful sense that you are flawed, unworthy or defective as a person, and that if people saw the real you, they would turn away. It’s usually felt in the body before it’s put into words: a hot face, a sinking stomach, wanting to shrink or disappear.
Everyone feels shame sometimes. It’s one of the emotions that tie us to other people, because it’s so closely linked to how we think others see us. The problem starts when shame stops being a passing feeling and becomes the lens you see yourself through.
Guilt vs shame: the difference
The difference is where the spotlight lands.
- Guilt focuses on a behavior: “I forgot her birthday.” Shame focuses on the self: “I’m a selfish person.”
- Guilt is usually tied to a specific moment. Shame tends to spread to everything.
- Guilt makes you want to repair: apologize, make amends, do it differently next time. Shame makes you want to hide, deny, blame someone else or get angry.
- Guilt keeps your attention on the person you hurt. Shame pulls your attention back onto yourself and how bad you feel.
Psychologists who study these emotions have found that people who tend toward guilt are more likely to take responsibility and try to make things right, while people who tend toward shame are more likely to withdraw, get defensive or turn the anger outward. That’s why heaping shame on yourself after a mistake rarely makes you a better person. It mostly makes you want to look away from what happened.
Signs shame is running the show
Chronic shame doesn’t always look like shame. It can look like:
- harsh self-talk that sounds like an inner critic who never sleeps
- trouble accepting compliments, or assuming people will eventually see through you
- apologizing constantly, even for things that aren’t your fault
- perfectionism, or avoiding anything you might fail at
- strong defensiveness when someone gives you even mild feedback
- hiding parts of your life, body, past or feelings from people close to you
- pleasing people so they don’t see the parts you think are unacceptable
- anger that flares when you feel exposed or criticized
If several of these fit, our posts on self-worth and perfectionism look at two of the places shame often hides.
Where chronic shame comes from
Shame is learned. Common roots include:
- growing up with a lot of criticism, contempt or ridicule, or with love that felt conditional on behaving well or achieving
- abuse or neglect in childhood, which children often make sense of by deciding something must be wrong with them
- bullying, or being singled out for your body, your family, your identity or how you learn
- trauma later in life, especially experiences that left you feeling powerless or exposed
- being told, directly or not, that parts of you, such as your sexuality, your feelings or your needs, were unacceptable
None of this means your shame is your parents’ fault, or anyone’s. It means shame usually started as a way to make sense of something painful, often when you were too young to make sense of it any other way.
What shame does to relationships
Shame is hard on closeness. When you feel exposed, you may shut down, get defensive or counterattack, and the person you love experiences you as cold or hostile, when inside you feel small. In a couple, two people’s shame can collide: one partner’s complaint lands as “you’re a failure,” and the reply lands the same way. That’s a common reason the same fight repeats. Couples therapy can help partners see the shame under the anger.
Recognize yourself here? You don’t need a diagnosis or a referral to start. Contact us and we will match you with a clinician licensed in your state, or check your insurance first.
How to start working with shame
Shame grows in hiding, so most of what helps involves bringing it into the light, slowly and with people who are safe.
- Name it. “This is shame” is a surprisingly useful sentence. It gives you a little distance from the feeling.
- Move from “I am” to “I did.” Rewrite the thought around the behavior: not “I’m a terrible parent,” but “I snapped, and I want to repair it.”
- Repair where you did harm. When guilt is pointing at something real, act on it: apologize, make amends, change the pattern. Repair is what guilt is for.
- Talk back to the inner critic. Ask whether you’d speak to a friend this way. If not, try saying what you’d say to them.
- Practice self-compassion. Self-compassion means treating yourself with the kindness you’d offer someone you care about, and remembering that mistakes are part of being human. It isn’t letting yourself off the hook; it’s what makes it bearable to look at what went wrong.
- Tell one safe person. Shame tends to lose some of its grip when it’s spoken to someone who doesn’t recoil.
How therapy helps with shame
Therapy gives shame somewhere to go other than inward. A good first step is simply saying the things you’ve never said, to someone who doesn’t flinch.
Every clinician at New Reflections Counseling uses cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which helps you catch global self-judgments (“I’m worthless”) and test them against the evidence. Internal Family Systems (IFS), offered in most of our states (not Tennessee, Rhode Island or Georgia), treats the inner critic as a part of you that is usually trying, clumsily, to protect you, and helps you relate to it differently. DBT-informed skills work, offered in Florida, Illinois, South Carolina, New York, North Carolina and Connecticut, can help when shame comes with intense emotions or urges. Our clinicians are trauma-informed, so if shame is rooted in abuse or trauma, that history is handled with care and at your pace.
There is no set number of sessions, and the pace is yours.
Common questions
Is guilt or shame worse?
Guilt usually does less damage, because it points at something you can do: repair the harm and change the behavior. Shame points at your whole self, which leaves nothing to fix and makes it harder to take responsibility. Guilt can become unhealthy too, though, when it’s constant or attached to things that aren’t your fault.
What is toxic shame?
“Toxic shame” isn’t a clinical diagnosis. It’s a popular term for shame that has become chronic and global, so that you feel defective at your core rather than bad about a specific moment.
What’s the difference between shame and embarrassment?
Embarrassment is usually lighter and shorter, tied to an awkward moment in front of others, and often something you can laugh about later. Shame goes deeper and is about who you are, and it can follow you long after everyone else has forgotten.
Can shame cause depression?
Shame and depression often go together, and research has linked a tendency toward shame with depression and anxiety. Feeling worthless or guilty most of the time can also be a sign of depression itself. If that sounds familiar, our depression self-check is a good place to start.
Does insurance cover therapy for shame?
Often, yes. Shame isn’t a billing diagnosis on its own, but therapy for the anxiety, depression or trauma that often comes with it usually is covered. We are in network with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare (including UMR plans), Blue Cross Blue Shield and Tricare, with some differences by state: Blue Cross Blue Shield is out of network in South Carolina and in network in Illinois only with Jaime Doss, Tricare is not in network in Illinois, and UnitedHealthcare is out of network in Illinois and not yet in network in Tennessee. We can verify your benefits free. Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples or family sessions, each 45–50 minutes, and $200–$250 for an extended 90-minute individual, couples or EMDR session.
Where We Work
We offer individual therapy by secure video in Florida, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, North Carolina, South Carolina, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Tennessee and Rhode Island, and couples therapy in every one of those states except Rhode Island. You need to be physically in the state at the time of your session. In-person sessions are available at our Wellington, Florida office; in-person times in Cary, North Carolina are full right now, so new North Carolina clients start by video. All New Jersey sessions are by secure video. Meet the clinicians on our therapists page.
- Self-Worth and Self-Acceptance: Stop Earning Your Place
- Perfectionism Therapy: Signs, Roots and What Helps
- Self-Sabotage: Why You Undo the Things You Want
- People Pleasing and Boundaries: Why Saying No Feels Dangerous
- When a Parent Cannot Meet You Emotionally: A Guide for Adult Children
- Imposter Syndrome: What It Is and How to Overcome It
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
