Christian Counseling: Therapy That Works With Your Faith
Plenty of people in Palm Beach County who go looking for a Christian therapist have already had the conversation they were dreading. They mentioned prayer and the room went quiet. They said the word “church” and watched it get filed under complication. They are not looking for a sermon, and they are not looking to be talked out of anything. They are looking for someone who will not flinch.
If that is where you are, you can request an appointment or check your insurance to get started. To be straight about scope: Christian counseling at New Reflections Counseling is offered in three states. In Florida, Dr. Kathy Altidor, LMHC, sees individuals and families in person at our Wellington office or by secure video anywhere in Florida. In South Carolina, Katharine Kilpatrick, LMFTA sees couples, including engaged couples, by secure video anywhere in the state. In New York, D’amber Pounds, MS, MFT-LP, can incorporate Christian beliefs into counseling for individuals, couples, families and teens, by secure video. It can sit alongside individual therapy, family therapy and grief and loss work. If you live outside Florida, New York and South Carolina, we can still help, just without this emphasis. The full list of states is further down.
What This Means Here, and What It Does Not
In Florida, Christian counseling here means working with Dr. Kathy Altidor, LMHC, a Florida-licensed mental health counselor who incorporates Christian beliefs into counseling. She sees clients in person at our Wellington office, 8461 Lake Worth Rd, Suite 248, Wellington, FL 33467, and by secure video anywhere in Florida. She works in English and also offers sessions in Haitian Creole.
What she is not: a pastor, a pastoral counselor or a biblical counselor. This is licensed clinical therapy that makes room for your faith. It is not a church ministry. We would rather tell you that up front than have you find out partway through.
What we do offer is straightforward. If you want your faith in the room, it is welcome, and it gets treated as a resource rather than something to work around. If prayer is how you steady yourself, that tells us something about what already helps you. If your church is where your community lives, that is a support network, not a variable to be controlled for. If scripture is the language you think in, you can think out loud in it. Kathy incorporates Christian beliefs into her counseling, and you can always tell her how much of that you want in a given session.
If what you actually want is counseling where scripture is the primary method, where the work is discipleship and the counselor speaks with spiritual authority, we are not that, and a church-based counseling ministry will serve you better. Saying so costs us a client and saves you time.
How Faith Actually Shows Up in a Session
Less often than people expect, and more usefully. It rarely looks like a theological discussion. It looks like your therapist knowing that when you say you feel convicted, you mean something specific, and not the same thing as guilt. It looks like not treating your decision to stay in a hard marriage as automatic evidence of low self-worth, and also not treating it as automatically noble, but asking what is actually holding it together.
It looks like understanding that “I prayed about it” is a real process with real steps, and asking what you heard rather than nodding politely and moving on. And sometimes it looks like nothing at all, because you came in about your teenager and your faith simply was not the relevant part that week.
When Your Faith and Your Therapy Seem to Disagree
This is the part most people are bracing for, so let us be direct about it. There are places where a therapist and a church can appear to pull in opposite directions, and pretending otherwise helps nobody.
Anxiety is the common one. If you have been told at some point that worry is a failure of trust, then having a panic disorder becomes two problems instead of one: the disorder, and the shame about having it. The anxiety gets treated as anxiety, with approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy. Nobody is going to adjudicate your theology, and nobody is going to reinforce a message that has been making you worse.
Forgiveness is the other one. People arrive believing they are obliged to forgive quickly, and that doing it properly means restored access for whoever hurt them. Those are two separate things, and separating them is often most of the work. You can forgive someone and still not let them near your children. A therapist who understands why that distinction feels dangerous to you will get further with it than one who has never considered it.
Want to talk it through first? Request an appointment, check your insurance, or call Wellington at (561) 288-0377.
What People Actually Come In With
Not, usually, a spiritual crisis. The presenting problems are the ordinary ones: a marriage that has gone cold, a parent dying, a job that has hollowed someone out, a nineteen-year-old who has stopped calling home. Faith is the context those things are happening inside, not the problem itself.
Grief is the one where it matters most. Bereaved people are often surrounded by others telling them their person is in a better place, which is meant kindly and lands as an instruction not to be sad. Being told you should feel comforted while feeling nothing of the sort is isolating in a specific way. Grief work here does not require you to resolve that. You are allowed to believe something and still be devastated by it.
The other frequent one is a person in their forties or fifties who has done everything the way they were taught to, married well, raised the children, served at church, and has arrived somewhere unexpectedly empty. That is not a loss of faith, and it is usually not depression in the textbook sense. It tends to be the point where a life built entirely on obligation runs out of road, and it is the kind of thing individual therapy is built for.
What the First Session Looks Like
The first step is an intake session. Mostly it is you talking and Kathy asking about ordinary things: how you sleep, what the week looks like, who you would call at two in the morning. Sessions are 45–50 minutes, whether you come to Wellington or join by video. Your faith is part of the conversation from the start, and you can say how you would like it to shape the work.
It is reasonable to ask directly, in that first session, how she works with this. Something as plain as “my faith matters to me and I do not want to have to explain that every week” is enough. You should leave knowing what you are working on and roughly how you plan to go about it. There is no set number of sessions. If the fit is wrong at any point, say so. Being matched with someone better suited is a good outcome, not a failed one.
What We Will Not Do
A short list, because it is the part people want in writing:
- Tell you what your faith requires of you. That is not our role and we are not qualified for it.
- Use scripture to move you toward a decision: staying, leaving, forgiving, reconciling. Christian beliefs are part of the work; pressure toward a particular decision is not.
- Treat doubt as a symptom. Periods of doubt are ordinary, and they are not what we are treating.
- Report to your pastor, your small group or anyone else. What happens in session is confidential in the ordinary clinical sense, and that does not change because you and your therapist share a faith.
- Pretend to a background she does not have. If you ask a theological question, you will get an honest “that is outside what I can speak to.”
Who This Is Not For
In Florida, Christian counseling is for individuals and families, not couples. Couples who want their faith in the room can work with Katharine Kilpatrick in South Carolina or D’amber Pounds in New York; elsewhere, we can match you with one of our couples therapists, without the faith emphasis.
If there is violence, threats or coercive control in your relationship, including control dressed in religious language, and you are in danger, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233, and it is confidential. Tell us when you get in touch and we will talk through what support fits.
This is outpatient therapy, not crisis care. If you are thinking about suicide or are in crisis, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, at any hour.
And if what you want is spiritual direction, or a counselor who speaks with church authority, a pastor or a church counseling ministry is the better fit.
Where This Is Available
Christian counseling is available in Florida, New York and South Carolina. In Florida, Kathy sees clients in person at our Wellington office, 8461 Lake Worth Rd, Suite 248, Wellington, FL 33467, which many locals think of as Lake Worth, and by secure video anywhere in the state. Florida licensure means you need to be physically in Florida at the time of each session, including video sessions.
In South Carolina, Katharine Kilpatrick, LMFTA works with couples, including engaged couples preparing for marriage, by secure video anywhere in the state, and you need to be physically in South Carolina during each session. In South Carolina we are in network with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare and Tricare. Read more about couples therapy in Greenville, SC, or call (843) 699-6220.
In New York, D’amber Pounds, MS, MFT-LP, can incorporate Christian beliefs into counseling for individuals, couples, families and teens. New York sessions are by secure video anywhere in the state, and you need to be physically in New York during each session. Call (914) 236-4450.
If you live in Connecticut or any other state outside Florida, New York and South Carolina, we cannot offer you Christian counseling. We would rather say so here than at intake. The practice has clinicians licensed in other states, and we can match you with one of them for couples, individual or family work, just without the faith integration this page describes.
If you split the year between Florida and somewhere else, you can see Kathy while you are in Florida. For the months you are away, ask about a clinician licensed in your other state.
When you call or fill in the contact form, say you are asking for Christian counseling. We will book you with Kathy (Florida), D’amber (New York) or Katharine (South Carolina) directly, rather than matching you on availability and leaving you to raise it in the first session.
Common Questions
Do I have to be a practicing Christian for this?
No. Some people come in having been raised in the church and left it, and want a therapist who understands what they are carrying without wanting them back in a pew. That is a legitimate reason to look for someone who speaks the language.
Will you pray with me?
Ask when you call, or ask Kathy directly in your first session. Kathy incorporates Christian beliefs into counseling, and how prayer fits is something to talk through with her, and if prayer is part of how you cope, no one will treat that as something to get past.
Are you affiliated with a church or ministry?
No. We are an independent group practice. No denomination, no oversight from any congregation, and no referral arrangement with one. That cuts both ways: nobody is vetting us theologically, and nobody is reporting back.
Do you offer Christian counseling for couples?
In South Carolina and New York, yes. Katharine Kilpatrick works with couples, including engaged couples, in South Carolina (see Christian couples counseling in South Carolina), and D’amber Pounds sees couples in New York. In Florida, Kathy’s Christian counseling is for individuals and families; if you want couples therapy there, we can match you with one of our couples therapists, without the faith emphasis.
Do you take insurance for this?
Yes, the same as any other session. In Florida, we are in network with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Tricare, Curative, MultiPlan and Oscar; in New York, with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Tricare, CDPHP, Northwell, First Health Network, MultiPlan and MagnaCare; in South Carolina, with Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare and Tricare. We do not accept Medicare or Medicaid. Self-pay is $125 per individual session and $175 for couples, family or EMDR. Sessions are 45–50 minutes. HSA and FSA cards are accepted, and we can provide a superbill if you plan to claim out-of-network benefits. There is no free consultation; the first step is an intake session. You can check your coverage here before booking.
Where We Work
Christian counseling is offered in Florida, New York and South Carolina. The practice as a whole works across twelve states, and if you are outside those three states we can still help, just without this emphasis.
Colorado · Connecticut · Florida · Georgia · Illinois · New Jersey · New York · North Carolina · Pennsylvania · Rhode Island · South Carolina · Tennessee
You can read about Kathy and the rest of the team on our therapists page, or call Wellington at (561) 288-0377.
Ready to start? Request an appointment and mention that you are looking for Christian counseling. It helps us book you with Kathy or Katharine the first time.
Ready to Talk It Through?
Christian counseling in Florida, in person in Wellington or by secure video statewide, and for couples in South Carolina by secure video.
Follow New Reflections Counseling on Instagram, TikTok and Facebook.
Prefer email? Subscribe to Ordinary to Ask and get our free guide, Your First Therapy Call.
